Interview with Literary Agent Caryn Wiseman

by on Mar.01, 2013, under Contests & Giveaways, Literary Agent Interviews

Caryn WisemanCaryn has been an agent with the Andrea Brown Literary Agency since early 2003, and has sold more than 175 books. She handles children’s books only: young adult and middle-grade fiction and non-fiction, chapter books, and picture books (fiction and non-fiction). She represents NYT bestselling authors, award-winning authors, debut authors, and authors at every stage in between. No matter the genre, Caryn is looking for books with emotional depth and a strong voice; excellent writing in a tightly-plotted, commercial story; and characters that stick with her long after she has closed the book. In YA, she gravitates toward books that make her think and toward books that make her cry; in middle-grade and chapter books, laughter tends to be the common thread. She loves books that are intellectually challenging and take risks, but in a very logical way. She wants to be surprised by interesting plot twists, but she never wants to question the motivations of characters.

Caryn is very drawn to speculative middle grade or YA fiction—whether contemporary with a very smart science fiction or light fantasy element, or a unique twist on paranormal or dystopian themes. Zombies, horror, and high fantasy will, most likely, not appeal. She would be thrilled to see more contemporary multicultural middle grade or YA—books that deeply explore another culture, as well as books in which the ethnicity of the character is not the issue. She adores a swoon-worthy romance with an intelligent heroine who isn’t simply swept off her feet by a hunky hero. She adores a sweet, funny or poignant middle-grade novel, with a great hook that makes it stand out from the crowd. She is always open to terrific children’s work that doesn’t fit these categories, however, as long as it makes her laugh, makes her cry, and keeps her awake at night, either reading the manuscript or thinking about it. A literary bent to a well-crafted commercial story in which ordinary characters find themselves in extraordinary situations would capture her attention. She loves lyrical, non-institutional picture book biographies, and children’s or teen nonfiction that reads like fiction; that has a great “story behind the story.” She does not represent adult projects. Please do not query her regarding adult work.

1. What is the best part of being a literary agent?

Fulfilling dreams! Telling an author that I’ve received an offer (or multiple offers) on their manuscript makes me giddy, and sometimes makes me cry (I’m a sap). Being part of the trajectory of a project from manuscript to actual physical book is amazing. After almost 10 years of agenting, I still get chills when I walk into a bookstore and see my clients’ books on the shelves. I also love to brainstorm with my clients, particularly when there are tough story issues to resolve.

2. How would you summarize your personal agenting philosophy? What do you expect from an agent-author relationship?

My personal agenting philosophy is to be honest and transparent with authors and with editors. I expect my authors to be honest in return. I only take on projects that I am passionate about. If I’m not passionate about your work, I’m not going to be able to sell it, even if it’s something commercial. I also hope that my authors will not be defensive, but will take time to think about editorial comments before responding negatively. This is a partnership, and it’s built on trust and mutual respect.

3. What’s something coming out now/soon that you’ve represented and are excited about?

THE GATHERING DARK by Christine Johnson is coming out on February 12th. It’s a YA novel that Booklist calls a “lusty romance made more so by its self-imposed repressed desire, a nod to astrophysics and the theory of dark matter, and a suspenseful adventure into another world, all grounded in references to classical piano repertoire.” Also, New York Times bestselling author Tom Angleberger’s Art2-D2’s Guide to Folding and Doodling: An ORIGAMI YODA Activity Book, will be out at the end of March. Kids are going to love it!

4. What are the primary mistakes you see writers make in the query process?

The biggest mistake that writers make is not following our submission guidelines. They are clearly spelled out on our website, and they are there for a reason. If you want me (or any of my colleagues) to take a look at your work, please follow the guidelines. Also, writers should personalize their e-queries. I only ask for exclusives for something that I’ve requested, so submitting to me exclusively is not going to increase your chances, and may delay your finding the right agent for you. Getting a query addressed to “Agent” or, even worse, addressed to the wrong agent, or more than one agent, is a big mistake. Submitting to more than one agent at our agency at the same time will usually lead to us all deleting it. We don’t want to waste our time. Finally, it is a big turn-off when writers don’t polish their query letters and/or pages. Have someone proofread your material. Watch grammatical and punctuation mistakes, and don’t write in text-speak. It makes you look unprofessional, and that puts you at a disadvantage. You only have one shot, so make it your best.

5. With fiction partials, what makes you stop reading and start skimming-or stop reading altogether?

I’ll stop reading at any point in a partial or full manuscript. It could be the first sentence; it could be the 200th page. A great voice can pull me in, but I’ll stop reading as soon as the story starts falling apart (and I’ll be sad and disappointed). A great story with page-turning pacing will keep me going, until I get to the point when I say “oh, come on!” and stop reading. A story that’s just plain boring, even if the voice is great, will turn me off when I get to the point that I realize nothing is going to happen.

6. Your agency website says that you’re interested in young adult, can you elaborate more on YA subgenres that you might consider?

Any and all except horror. Given today’s market, if you’ve got something paranormal or speculative, it needs to be unique and it needs to stand out from the crowd that’s already out there. I hate to say no to something that could be an amazing twist on themes that have been explored before, but dystopian is a pretty tough sell right now, so if you’ve got something dystopian, it’s unlikely that I’ll take it on, unless it has an amazingly fresh and unique spin. Same with paranormal. I’m not usually drawn to high fantasy, particularly if it requires maps, but if it’s something fresh and amazing, I’m open. Right now, I’d love to see a great contemporary YA – either completely realistic, or with a very smart science fiction or light fantasy element. No zombies, horror, or high fantasy. I adore a swoon-worthy romance with an intelligent heroine who isn’t simply swept off her feet by a hunky hero. Voice is paramount, but the writing and story need to be amazing, too. Specifically, I’d love to see a YA thriller with the pacing and twists of HOMELAND a YA Downton Abbey, a Southern gothic romance, and a YA Glee or Pitch Perfect or Big Bang Theory. I’d also be happy with a non-dystopian science fiction or light fantasy, in which the world-building just carries me off.

For middle-grade, I’d love to see something hysterically funny that isn’t a one-trick pony, or a voice-driven, poignant story like WONDER, or a sweeping, epic adventure. I also love literary middle-grade like WHEN YOU REACH ME, as long as it has a great hook or twist.

7. When accepting fantasy and sci-fi, what subgenres do you lean toward?

I tend to like light sci-fi and light fantasy, grounded in reality, or contemporary fiction with a sci-fi or fantasy twist. I don’t tend to like fantasy that requires maps or involves elves and great quests. On the other hand, if you have built an amazing world that I’ve never seen before, I’d be open to taking a look.

8. Will you be at any upcoming writers conferences where people can meet/pitch you?

Big Sur, VA Festival of the Book, SCBWI Northern California

9. Is a writing platform important for unpublished writers? Does it weigh in on your decision to represent? Are you a fan of social media?

A writing platform is not important for unpublished fiction writers. For nonfiction, a platform can be important if you’re an expert in a certain area, but not as important as in adult non-fiction. That being said, an author who is already out there on social media is a big plus. Authors have to promote themselves, so someone who is social media savvy and well-connected will catch my eye if their manuscript is amazing. But, if you’re writing YA fiction, don’t worry that you have to get out there and establish some sort of platform before submitting your work.

10. Best piece(s) of advice we haven’t discussed?

Never stop reading, particularly in the category that you’re interested in. Just because you’re a fabulous YA author, it doesn’t mean that you know how to write middle-grade or picture books. Don’t try to write to trends; you can’t catch them. Write the best book that you want to write. Develop a thick skin, and keep it on. Always remember that this is a subjective business, and, just because one agent or editor doesn’t like something, doesn’t mean that another won’t fall in love with it. It only takes one. On the other hand, if a number of professionals are giving you similar suggestions about your work, it might be worth listening. Check your hubris at the door, but bring your passion with you everywhere that you go.

a Rafflecopter giveaway

:, , ,

37 Comments for this entry

  • Nicole Zoltack

    Great interview! The hardest part for me is the beginning of a story. I write and rewrite and change them so many times before I finally get it right.

  • Natalie Aguirre

    The most difficult part of writing for me is probably character development. I’ve had other struggles too and I learn as I go.

    Caryn sounds like a fabulous agent. I have a multi-cultural middle grade novel, but it’s high fantasy. So sadly, I know it’s not for her. It was interesting to read her process of when she stops reading partial and full manuscripts. Thanks for all the advice.

  • Marcy Blesy

    The hardest part of writing for me is simply finding the time between work and family obligations. Then I have to battle the negative ninny in my brain, too! ;-)

  • carrie pearson

    The hardest part of writing for me is pushing the world away. Words flow when when I give them time!

  • Andrew Patterson

    The hardest part of writing is, besides finding the time, is when the story gets so loud in my head that I can’t think of anything else. That is also the scariest part in some ways.

  • BJ Whittington

    Interesting, lots of good info here. I am thinking about a middle-school chapter book so it is good to see what is in demand.

  • Ann Finkelstein

    The hardest part for me seems to change with the manuscript. For my last novel, I was asked at a novel workshop to switch the main character with the secondary character. I never found the new character’s voice. This time, my descriptive passages need some beefing up.

  • Susan Crispell

    The hardest part for me is making the stakes higher. I tend to make the stakes very emotional for the protagonist and I’m realizing that’s not enough. She needs to have more external conflict to make her story/journey mean something.

  • Deena

    ORIGAMI YODA author is coming to Rochester’s Teen Book Fest this May, and I can’t wait to meet him!

    • Deena

      My most difficult part of writing is STAYING FOCUSED while there are so many other things going on in my brain but I really just need to get the words on the page.

  • Vanessa Levin-Pompetzki

    The hardest part of writing for me is to remember to take it slow. I can get SO caught up in the characters, the story, and everything that I know will happen—then I tend to rush parts of the story that need more focus. I often find myself going back to flesh those parts out. I have to remember to give all of my novel the same loving care.

  • Maria

    Learning not to take criticism personally. I take the whole process so personally, but I need to distance myself during the revision process to get the most out of it.

  • Jennifer Rumberger

    This was a great post to read. The hardest part of writing for me is finding the time to write. I need to learn to take snippets of time and use them wisely. Three snippets throughout the day can be just as good as one hour long session.

  • Cheryl Malandrinos

    Wonderful interview. I got a chance to make an online pitch to Ms. Wiseman a few years back at The Muse Online Writers Conference. It was a great–and nerve-wracking–experience. I’m so glad I did it.

    The hardest part of writing for me is the editing stage. I am not a strong self-editor. I can edit other people’s work, picking up errors and inconsistencies, but when it comes to do it for myself, I stink. :)

  • TF Walsh

    Thanks for the great opportunity. Hmmm, most difficult part is getting chapter 1 right…

  • Angela Peña Dahle

    This is a fantastic opportunity! Thanks!

  • Emi

    Thanks for the interview – this is great!

  • DLM

    I have no patience for character-lollygagging or blah-blah-blah dialogue, so I tend to rush through my scenes with hardly a breeze getting through.

  • Deborah Kreiser

    Thank you for the interview. It’s always so helpful to hear specifics on what an agent is looking for.

  • Meredith

    The hardest part of writing for me is staying focused. There are so many distractions in life (kids, work, the darn phone, twitter) that I find it hard to sit and write for any length of time. It drives me crazy.

  • Keely Dunn

    A very helpful interview, thanks for sharing it!

  • Jamie Grey

    What a great opportunity and a fantastic interview!

  • Linda McLaren

    Caryn is wonderful!
    Good luck to you all! : )

  • Veronica Bartles

    The hardest part of writing for me is knowing when to let go of a story. I revise compulsively, over and over again… send it off to CPs for feedback… revise again… find new CPs for a fresh perspective and more feedback… more revisions… All on an endless loop forever and ever. And I never know when to say, “this is enough” and start submitting. (As a result, I now have 2 YA novels, 2 MG novels, a handful of PBs and a book about knitting with recycled plastic bags, and I’m still working on all of them! My goal this year is to gain the confidence to start sending a manuscript or two out into the world.)

  • Nanci

    Great interview! I have followed Caryn on Twitter.

  • Laura Johnston

    What a great interview. I would LOVE to have Caryn critique my query. The hardest part about writing is ending a story–it’s just so much fun to live in the world of the story! Feels like leaving a good friend behind.

  • Jenni

    The hardest part of writing for me is finding the time to write. With three young children I am being pulled in so many different directions, yet I know when I am not writing a part of me feels completed disconnected. My goal is to write everyday, whether I’m writing at midnight, while I’m waiting to pick my kids up from school or at five in the morning when everyone is still asleep. Writing helps me clarify who I am. It helps me find meaning in the world and illuminates what is truly important.

  • Jessica Capelle

    The most difficult part of writing for me is writing action and movement- I worry that I sound like I’m doing choreography or something! :-) Also finding large blocks of time to write since I get better quality work done when I can immerse myself in it.

    Thanks for the great contest!

  • Stacey Nash

    For me, the hardest part is knowing when to stop revising, editing, tweaking. Every time I open the file on a finished manuscript I find something else I want to tweak.

  • Debbie Cocchio

    I think the most difficult part for me is the editing. I find that I tend to switch tenses without realizing it. I just let the writing flow, then I have to deal with it later.

  • Ramona Siddoway

    The most difficult part of writing is the tense. I find myself switching between present tense and past tense, usually because often I am reading one tense for pleasure while writing another tense for my own manuscript.

  • Jenn Baker (@jbakernyc)

    The hardest part is definitely in the revision stage when trying to problem solve. The first draft goes freely but when tackling what needs to be fixed it can be a bit of a struggle at times.

  • Brooks Benjamin

    This was excellent.

    My biggest fear with my query is that it won’t stand out in the sea of other queries as much as I want it to. Trying to find what an agent considers really unique and sellable is something I’d like to know more about. I’ve read books in my genre and believe I have something unique enough to make potential buyers want to pick it up, but… I know I could make my query stand out so much more.

  • Kathleen S. Allen

    The hardest part for me is when I get to around 12,000 words I lose momentum and sometimes have trouble getting it back. I have a great idea, start writing and somewhere around the middle…nothing. Crickets. I have a YA mystery with a teen boy as the MC she might like. I’m just starting to query it. Thanks for the opportunity!

  • Kara

    The hardest part of writing for me is ignoring the self doubt and plugging away at that first draft.

  • Regina Castillo

    The hardest part of writing is getting started! Putting my bottom in the chair and writing!

  • Regina Castillo

    Thanks for the interview. It was awesome information.
    The hardest part of writing for me is getting started.

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: