How Amazon Plans to Destroy E-Book Sales (as it has Most of the Publishing Industry)

by on Feb.08, 2013, under Publishing

Amazon KindleLooks like the publishing industry is set to take another hit from Amazon. This one will be what kills e-book sales. Yesterday, Publishers Weekly announced, ‟the mega-retailer has its sights on digital resale, including used e-books and audio downloads. According to the abstract, Amazon will be able to create a secondary market for used digital objects purchased from an original vendor by a user and stored in a user’s personalized data store.”

I’m going to attempt to explain what this means: If person A buys an e-book from Amazon Kindle, they can resell the e-book to person B at a lower price because the e-book is now deemed used. The license moves from person A to B, and supposedly once person A has sold it, they can no longer view the e-book in their device. Just to be clear, both the author and publisher of the e-book receive no compensation from the sale to person B. Also, person B can choose to sell the e-book to person C, and it works just the same as above.

Maybe you’re asking, ‟Why does this matter? Amazon already sells used print books and authors are still making money?”

Here’s a great example. In October 2012, I ran the promotions for the second e-book in J. Lynn’s Gamble Brothers series, Tempting the Player. That month, the promotions of the second e-book boosted sales of the first e-book (Tempting the Best Man) causing it to land on the USA TODAY bestsellers list for the first time. The e-book, Tempting the Best Man, was released in May, 2012.

Let’s pretend Amazon’s secondary e-book market was already in place when Tempting the Best Man was released. Since the e-book was available for six months, there’s a good chance used copies would’ve been available. Meaning, the first e-book would’ve never hit the bestsellers list because secondary sales are not counted toward the lists, and as I already stated, the author receives no compensation for secondary sales. There’s no way for me to prove it wouldn’t have been a bestseller, but I’m confident readers would’ve purchased the cheaper digital if given the option.

Overall, it’s a major hit to an already dwindling market. You can thank Amazon personally for the loss of Borders and most of the other bookstore closings over the last few years. They simply can’t compete with used print book sales. And, this new development will make it even worse for booksellers, publishers, and authors. I expect e-book only authors to take the greatest hit. I mean, why would someone buy a new e-book from the publisher/author when they can buy used (but not really used because it’s digital) at a lower cost? Not to mention, the e-books can be sold over and over and over again (see outline above) without the burden of having to mail anything yourself.

In my opinion, Amazon has become the Walmart of the publishing industry, and I wonder how long the publishers/authors/booksellers can take these ginormous hits before the whole system as we know it crumbles at their feet.

Stacey O’Neale is a freelance writer, book blogger, and a senior publicist with Entangled Publishing. She has participated in panels at Book Expo America and the Virginia Festival of the Book. In addition, she teaches social media and publicity courses through Savvy Authors.

Special thanks to CNN Money for this pic.

:, , ,

10 Comments for this entry

  • Gaby

    I’m a reader but even to me this seems totally unfair and it’s definitely a low blow to authors who do their best in writing books but find themselves affected by this. This can’t happen.

  • Vanessa

    So if i understand this, a person now has the right to resell their e-book. I don’t want to sound like a hypocrite but I do buy my textbooks for school used because let’s face it, college textbooks are really expensive.

    But reselling an e-book? That makes no sense. So a self-published author sells their book for $0.99, a reader buys the book for that price, then the reader is going to sell said book and sell it for less than $0.99? And now the original buyer of the book is not going to be able to re-read the book? What happens if you then decide to reread you have to purchase the book all over again.But we should also remember, the owners of the ebooks don’t really own the book, Amazon can take your books away whenever they want to. Traditional publishing is already tanking, but this is going to hurt authors and publishers, and soon authors won’t be writing, no more books turned into film, etc. The writing world will come crumbling down.

    All these crazy things Amazon is doing is making me happy that I own a NookColor and buy all of my books from Barnes and Noble.

    Thank you for letting me comment!

  • Lisette Brodey

    I REALLY hope that this does not come to be. Amazon thinks they are so big that nothing can touch them. This is horrible. It is really bad enough that some people don’t understand why digital editions of books have any value at all because they’re not printed on paper. But that’s another subject to rant about. I know there are some readers out there who would buy “new” no matter what to support the author. I certainly would. But sadly, I know I’m in the minority.

    Amazon should not bite the hand that feeds them. I hope that collectively we can get the word out to Amazon that this would indeed be a very BAD thing to do. It really sickens me.

    Thank you for writing this post, Stacey, and for letting everyone know just exactly what Amazon is proposing.

    Best,
    Lisette

  • Kel

    Even as one who is against e-books, I think this seems unfair. I personally will never purchase an e-book, as I can’t stand them, but it’s still unfair for authors to get jipped out of sales. At least with used real books, there’s still some compensation. *shakes head*

  • Ellen Faith

    This is completely ridiculous and unfair. I’m pro e-book (because Australia usually only gets the best sellers and we miss out on the other interesting reads), but this concept cannot go through.

    Amazon is killing our book industry with their every move.

  • Jstark

    How do you know an author won’t get a % of the used sale? Are you basing that on how this kind of transaction works with paper books? If so, I don’t think you can.

    First, Amazon has always been incredibly fair to authors, and their entire business is based on customer service. Since authors are their customers when it comes to where they upload their books, it makes sense to keep them happy.

    Everything Amazon does makes sense.

    Second, Amazon got the patent to sell used digital files in case the ReDigi lawsuit fails, and it applies mainly to music and video files.

    There is no way Amazon can start selling used digital files of books, music, and movies and expect to survive. They will be killing the industries that create the content, and that doesn’t make sense. And remember…

    Everything Amazon does makes sense.

    They are rebuilding the publishing industry in their image, and that includes how authors get paid. I think one thing self published writers don’t quite grasp is that the 70% royalty you all complain about… it’s a freakin gift from God to those of us who started doing this professionally long before Amazon stepped in and saved the entire industry.

    Whine and moan all you guys want, pretend Amazon is the evil empire who are for some reason feeding insane amount of money into self published authors bank accounts while secretly plotting ways to destroy you.

    I’m sorry, but that just doesn’t make sense.

  • robert

    It looks like Amazon is doing all it can to destroy the independent author. It has removed perfectly legitimate positive reviews and allowed fraudulent negative reviews to remain; it has removed tags that help readers find books; and now this!

    • What???

      Congratulations Robert, you just won the award for the dumbest comment on the internet.

      Amazon is the ONLY reason the term ‘Independent Author’ exists. They are the only reason self publishing is a viable option for unpublished, or as they like to be called, indie authors. The self publishing movement exists because Amazon allows it to exist, and if they wanted to destroy indie authors, all they’d have to do is flick the switch, take away the platform, take away the incredibly generous 70% royalty, and take away the dreams of the unpublished masses everywhere.

      Instead of bemoaning what Amazon is doing wrong, in your opinion, you’d be better to smile and nod and shut your mouth and thank whatever God you believe in that Amazon allows you to pretend to be a published author.

  • robert

    Your ignorance does not help to shore up your point. Independent authorship has existed for centuries–Amazon has just provided a more public platform and has reaped a fortune from authors “pretending” to be published (and whose books are many times far better than those published by traditional houses). Even if, for reasons of its own, Amazon bails on this gravy train, Nook, Kobo, Apple, and others will pick up the slack and reap the rewards. The independent author will always be ready to entertain the public.

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: