My Critique from the Pitch On Contest – LOSING IT by Lauren McKellar
by Stacey O'Neale on Oct.04, 2012, under Contests & Giveaways
Name: Lauren McKellar
Email: HIDDEN
Title: LOSING IT
Genre: Contemporary YA
Word Count: 46,000
17 year-old Amy is abandoned by her rock star father and sent to live in a country town. Drinking, partying, and falling for the wrong guy sees Amy spin from depression to self-destruct mode, as her dangerous habits spiral out of control.
When faced with a friend’s overdose, Amy can no longer hide from her past; she has to stop losing herself and face her future before it’s too late.
My Two Cents:
This sounds like it could be really good and deeply emotional. I would give it a read for sure! The major issue I see is the word count. Most guidelines state that a contemporary YA must be above 55,000 words. This could cause you to be rejected even before someone reads your query. The other issue is I’m not reading much in terms of a plot. What happens to Amy because of all the self-destructive behavior? Is the friends death her fault? I’m not seeing your story structure.
I played with the wording a bit and this is what I came up with:
After being abandoned by her rock star father, seventeen-year-old Amy is sent to live (with who?). Her depression and self-loathing quickly lead to drinking, partying, and falling for the wrong guy. A friend’s overdose forces her to confront her past and change her future before it’s too late.
Good luck!!!
Stacey O’Neale is a writer, book blogger, and a senior publicist with Entangled Publishing. She has participated in panels for Book Expo America and teaches courses through Savvy Authors. Beyond her websites and speaking engagements, you can find her on Goodreads, Twitter, and Facebook.



October 6th, 2012 on 3:00 am
Thank you so much Stacey! This is a great critique
I’ve been thinking on it all day… Am considering fleshing out some earlier points in the story, now, too. I’d hate to be not considered due to word count when there is so much more I could add!
All the best,
Lauren
October 6th, 2012 on 8:02 am
I’m glad you found my comments helpful. Good luck!