My Critique from the Pitch On Contest – VEILED by Katherine Ernst and Chelle Bruhn

by on Oct.01, 2012, under Contests & Giveaways

Names: Katherine Ernst and Chelle Bruhn

Email: Hidden

Country of residence: United States

Title: VEILED

Genre: YA Science Fiction

Word-count: 87,000

Pitch: When her sister kills herself to avoid an arranged marriage Aveza knows it’s because, in their world, women are genetically predisposed to take on the personality desired by their husbands, and Linza would rather die than be attached to someone so revolting.  Now Aveza is promised to him in her sister’s place, and she has two options: flee the only home she’s ever known or follow Linza into the grave.

My Two Cents:

Well, I can tell you I’m already intrigued and I love the title. I would give this a read for sure.

With that said, I would suggest you elaborate more on this world and why women are forced into this procedure. Also, how does this personality change take place? Is it a chip or a pill or a surgery? The idea is very interesting, and in my opinion, the most appealing/unique aspect of your pitch. If you needed to, I would take out the sister’s portion. The idea that Aveza is heading into an arranged marriage with someone she detests in really enough explanation. I tried to shorten your text to give you more room to explain it.

Shortened Word Pitch: After her sister kills herself to avoid an arranged marriage with a revolting man, Aveza is chosen to take her place. She refuses to accept the procedure which will shift her personality into what’s most appealing to her future husband and is ultimately left with two options: flee the only home she’s ever known or follow Linza to the grave.

Good luck!!!

Stacey O’Neale is a writer, book blogger, and a senior publicist with Entangled Publishing. She has participated in panels for Book Expo America and teaches courses through Savvy Authors. Beyond her websites and speaking engagements, you can find her on Goodreads, Twitter, and Facebook.

:, ,

5 Comments for this entry

  • Emilyann Girdner

    This concept is very interesting, but it took me a minute to grasp. I feel like Stacey’s suggestion to expound a bit on exactly in what way these women are forced to be the wives their husband’s want.
    Also, it is really nice that we see some of her motivations and feel for her because of her situation and sister’s death, but maybe there could be a little more reaction of the protagonist. I feel like I understand the premise and it is intriguing but I don’t have a very clear sense of who Avesa is.

    I’m really excited about this project. Good luck on this :)

  • Katherine and Chelle

    Thank you so much for the feedback! The clarity issue is exactly what we were struggling with. It’s actually not a procedure, per se, but that women have a genetic imperative to “become compatible” to any man who touches them, or (in the case of marriage) creates a blood tie with them. That’s definitely a lot to condense into seventy words, but we’ve rewritten the pitch and would love to hear your feedback.

    In Eskafalia women control nothing, not even their own minds. When a woman’s skin is exposed to the touch of a man, biology dictates that she’s forced to take on the personality he desires. A thin veil stands between Aveza and having her mind enslaved by the man her father has chosen for her. Her sister burned herself alive to avoid the same fate, but Aveza has a different plan.

  • Lauren McKellar

    I love your new pitch – I read your initial and thought it was good but did need a little clarity. I think involving the father as a figurehead helps, too, explaining why they need to do this in the first place.

    Good luck :)

Leave a Reply