Interview with Literary Agent Courtney Miller-Callihan
by Stacey O'Neale on Feb.03, 2012, under Literary Agent Interviews, Writing/Publicity Articles
Courtney began her career in publishing at Random House, where she spent a number of years in subsidiary rights sales and in contracts before joining Sanford J. Greenburger Associates in 2005. A member of the Romance Writers of America, she is seeking new voices in women’s fiction, romance, historical novels, and literary fiction. Courtney also looks for non-fiction projects on unusual topics, science, personal finance, business, pop culture, lifestyle books, and craft books. Excellent credentials are a must. She represents a limited number of children’s book authors and illustrators. Courtney holds a B.A. in Literature from the University of California, Santa Cruz and a M.A. in English from The Johns Hopkins University. She prefers to receive submissions via e-mail at cmiller [at] sjga [dot] com.
The Interview
1. What is the best part of being a literary agent?
I’ve always loved to read, and being a literary agent means spending all day, every day, thinking about and talking about books. I get to help writers make their dreams come true, which sounds cheesy but is a pretty fabulous job.
2. How would you summarize your personal agenting philosophy? What do you expect from an agent-author relationship?
I am very hands-on with my clients and their projects—I see it as part of my job to help make the manuscript into the best book it can be. I only work on projects I really believe in, and I hope my passion for the work is always clear to my authors, even if the feedback is sometimes hard to hear.
As for what I expect, first and foremost it’s important to be professional. Most authors have day jobs. Everyone has a personal life, and emergencies, and days when they just want to ignore all their responsibilities. I know authors are balancing a lot of stuff besides their writing, but I expect them to keep their word regarding deadlines and other obligations, and to treat writing as a job. Because if you’re lucky, it will be your job.
3. What’s something coming out now/soon that you’ve represented and are excited about?
Lots of things! To name two, first of all, Vicky Alvear Shecter’s debut YA novel CLEOPATRA’S MOON will be released this summer by Arthur A. Levine Books (Scholastic).
I’m also immensely proud of Pamela Schoenewaldt’s debut (adult) novel WHEN WE WERE STRANGERS, which was published earlier this year by HarperCollins, and was chosen by Barnes and Noble for their Discover Great New Writers program.
4. What are the primary mistakes you see writers make in query process?
Misspelling my name (or, worse, using the wrong name). Not following the query guidelines on my website. Querying me on genres I don’t represent. Not selling their work (and themselves!) effectively enough to make me want to read the manuscript.
5. With fiction partials, what makes you stop reading and start skimming-or stop reading altogether?
The two things I see causing the most problems are (1) the voice—do I like this character? Do I want to spend 300 pages with this character? And (2) good old “show, don’t tell.” Think long and hard about whether you need that much exposition up front. Sometimes leaving things a bit mysterious gives your reader the momentum to keep turning pages.
6. Your agency profile says that you’re interested in a limited amount of children’s, can you elaborate more on subgenres that you might consider (example: fantasy)?
I don’t do straight fantasy (in the Robin McKinley vein), but I like novels with some fantastical or supernatural elements. I like dark, issue-driven YA (not too after school special or moralistic) and funny middle grade. I’d love to see more “crime fiction,” especially for YA readers. I don’t much care for rhyming picture books, talking animals, or Holocaust stories. Really I’ll consider anything as long as it feels fresh and original.
7. When accepting romance, what subgenres do you lean toward?
I’m especially fond of Regency historicals, but I read widely across all genres. I don’t like “old school” romances with dominant heroes and submissive heroines. I’d love to see more historical romance in periods that haven’t been done to death—after Downtown Abbey, for example, I couldn’t stop wishing for an Edwardian series. But I’m actively looking for new clients in romance and women’s fiction, so please query me!
8. Will you be at any upcoming writers conferences where people can meet/pitch you?
Yes! I’ll be at the RWA national conference at the end of June, doing a two-hour pitch session on Friday morning.
9. What’s the best way to contact you?
Via email at cmiller [at] sjga [dot] com.
10. Best piece(s) of advice we haven’t discussed?
The most important thing is to believe in your own work. Write what you love, rather than writing to the current trends. Books take at least a year to be published, and what seems like the hot new thing today could be yesterday’s news long before a book hits the shelves.




