Alex Pettyfer Doesn’t Deserve the Role of Jace Wayland
by Stacey O'Neale on Mar.20, 2011, under City of Bones Movie
It seems that since the film adaption of City of Bones was announced, Alex Pettyfer was the lead contender for the role of Jace Wayland. Few can argue that Pettyfer resembles the description of Jace. He looks like he could’ve posed for the cover of the book, but I’d like to move past the physical likeness and discuss the problems with Pettyfer. Before I begin, I’d like to preface by saying that I was once a major Alex supporter, but the last two months have really sent me in the opposite direction. Now, I’m pleading with fans to throw their support behind another more deserving actor and I’ll explain why.
Alex has an attitude problem. He’s had some well documented issues on movie sets. Most notably, the Hollywood Reporter and other news sources reported multiple issues during the filming of I am Number Four. Apparently, Alex was miffed that another actor was making more money than he was. That led to him refusing to cash his paychecks for two months which gives me the mental picture of a toddler stomping his feet. During that same period of time, he also had issues with the director and the situation got so bad that a DreamWorks CEO had to intervene. The bad behavior continued when he missed marketing meetings for Beastly and left producers waiting for more than two hours. Recently, he was late to his own premier. Reports initially said it was because of the house fire, but the actor wasn’t home during the fire. Alex was late due to personal issues, but his PR company tried unsuccessfully to sweep additional bad press under the rug. In addition, the fire was limited to the garage and very little damage was done. Some have said that the press is picking on him, but too many people have come out with detailed accounts of this behavior. At some point, you have to use common sense. If it walks like a spoiled brat and acts like a spoiled brat then he’s probably a spoiled brat.
Alex has shown no passion for the role when he should be grateful. Jace Wayland is an incredible character and every actor in town seems to know that except for Pettyfer. Alex was offered the role, but insisted on a 10 million dollar paycheck when he only received 250K for his previous role in I Am Number Four. So what constitutes the huge raise? Surely it’s not tickets sales because both of his 2010 movies have under-achieved at the box office. So why does he deserve it? The answer is he doesn’t. He’s banking on the fact that fans want him in this role. His priority is the money. My guess is that he will land with whichever franchise is willing to pay out whether it’s City of Bones, The Last Apprentice, or Hunger Games. In addition to poor tickets sales, I wasn’t impressed with his acting talent and I’m not alone. Most of the extremely poor critical reviews of both movies have said that Alex has failed to deliver any emotion in either role. Mortal Instruments fans know that Jace is a complicated character who requires an actor with range. Alex is unproven, if not disappointing.
This is where I am hoping the book fans pay attention. I love this series and I want to see all the books brought to life. Jace is the essential role and everyone knows it. Do you really want to take a chance on an actor with obvious issues? An actor who hasn’t delivered on talent or ticket sales. What do you think will happen if City of Bones is the success that I expect it will be? Do you think his ego will get bigger or smaller? The answer is bigger which means he could mess up the entire chemistry on set. Is this the chance you’re willing to take with your beloved series because Alex happens to look like the Jace your mind? I’d prefer to have an unknown come in with acting talent who can give us the Jace we deserve. An actor who wants the role and would bite off his own arm to get it. That’s the commitment I’m looking for and certainly what Cassandra Clare deserves for writing such an outstanding series.
On a personal note, I’d like to thank everyone who’s participated in my articles or has spoken about it on the Mortal Instruments message boards. Whether you agree with me or not, I am truly honored to be part of your discussions.
167 Comments for this entry
1 Trackback or Pingback for this entry
-
Alex Pettyfer non merita il ruolo di Jace? | Shadowhunters Italia
March 28th, 2011 on 11:26 am[...] Vi lascio con un articolo scritto da una lettrice di YA e fan della serie. In quest’articolo la ragazza spiega perché Pettyfer non merita il ruolo. Ovviamente io non sono affatto daccordo, ma fatemi sapere la vostra opinione. Clicca. [...]


March 20th, 2011 on 12:33 am
I couldn’t have said it better myself. I too was once hoping that he would land the role of Jace, but after seeing I Am Number 4, I’m not so sure. I still think that looks wise he is the ideal Jace, but I adore the books too much to have the movies ruined. I mean, look what happened Twilight. They couldn’t have made a bigger mess of it if they tried.
March 21st, 2011 on 6:20 pm
Amen sister! Agree 100!
March 20th, 2011 on 12:34 am
I’m starting to agree with you. At first, I was all “No one but Alex” and I don’t think he’s a bad actor, and I’m not going to make any personal judgements on someone I don’t know (I’m not saying that you are, their is an large amount of bad press about him but I’d have to meet him myself before I said anything) but I think the person who plays Jace should want to. I’m not going to throw a fit if he is cast but I’m more open than ever for someone else to play him.
March 20th, 2011 on 12:38 am
I absolutely agree to your points about Jace needing to be an actor who has a lot of depth to them. He’s one of the most complex character I’ve come across and one I do enjoy reading about. Even if the actor looks exactly like the physical appearance of the character, he wouldn’t be able to replicate the emotional depth behind the character unless he was an exceptional actor, which you’re stating Alex isn’t.
I personally didn’t go to see Beastly because the previews didn’t look engaging enough. I’m definitely going to see City of Bones.
I also wouldn’t want someone who always acts like a spoiled brat playing one of the characters I write about. If they can’t act exactly the way a memorable character was written, than they shouldn’t!
March 20th, 2011 on 1:02 am
You are so right on so many levels.
March 20th, 2011 on 3:05 am
A-freaking-men.
That’s exactly my opinion on it and the more I get to know about his rather ugly character the more his looks lose appeal for me. Okay, he still is pretty and all that but has anyone ever paid attention to his nose? Obviously I hadn’t until recently but he does have a fugly nose
April 10th, 2011 on 5:07 am
YES!! I noticed his nose the first time I saw him!! Maybe it’s because I have a weird thing with noses but hey, he does have a problem doesn’t he? Not saying that he isn’t still perfect for the “look” of Jace. I was also one who only wanted Alex and only Alex but now.. I’m having doubts too.
March 20th, 2011 on 6:49 am
I have to say that I prefer someone else (preferably a new face) to portray Jace, but to say that Alex doesn’t deserve the role? I don’t agree with you. Have you ever seen Tormented? He was pretty good in that movie. His character, Bradley, is the bad guy who picks on everyone and has his little group of friends who loves to make fun of this other guy who died because of them. Jace is also this bad boy that has this very arrogant and cocky side, although he can be very sweet and vulnerable at times. His other roles, such as Freddie in Wild Child, Kyle in Beastly; and John in I Am Number Four, are the good guys of the story, of course the movie genres are not the same… (IANF is action packed while the others aren’t). I know that Jace is such a complex character, but in my opinion, he could portray Jace with no problem, I think he’s better at portaying this kind of characters…
As of the “attitude problem” and insisting on more money, I am on his side. I mean, he KNOWS that the fandom wants him, right? So, why not taking advantage of that and ask for more money? After all, the producers said that they wouldn’t make the movies if he doesn’t play Jace. Now, I don’t know if that’s a rumor or not, but it’s pretty obvious that he’s what they want. Everything revolves around money now, people shouldn’t be surprised… And what if he arrived late at the premiere? I don’t know why people make a whole big deal out of this. But who knows, maybe he wants to be considered as Hollywood’s newest bad guy. Tabloids have to leave the poor guy alone.
March 20th, 2011 on 6:14 pm
Stephanie that is a LIE,THEY WILL NOT stop making the movies if they dont get Alex,and this has already been confirmed by Cassandra Clare on her Google Group The_Mortal_Instruments.And NO he shouldnt take advantage and ask for 10 million dollars,why if he absolutly sucks Like Edward on Twilight COB will be the first of 4(counting City of fallen angels out soon) so why should he even get that much when his last movies sucked and he didnt get barely any money for it? I sure as hell think the 3 main ppl from Twilight dont deserve 20 million for each of the movies.Just because Alex was good in one or two movies doesnt mean he’s right for Jace and not only is Jace the bad boy he has a soft sweet and charming side that is totally diff form the bad boy side..AFter all the bad things weve heard about him,and all the other choices Ive seen City of Bones DESERVES better,and if everything with making th emovie goes right it will be biger than Twilight,which god know how bad they messed those up.
March 20th, 2011 on 8:14 pm
Oh then it was just a rumor. Well, I just don’t wanna believe in what those tabloids say about him. It just makes me mad. And I just keep thinking that maybe this role will be the one who marks his acting career? Who knows, right?
Still, I really hope someone else gets the role. I’m not part of the whole “Alex Pettyfer for Jace!!” team, but I just thought that saying that Alex doesn’t deserve the role was kind of rude.
March 28th, 2011 on 10:07 am
I totally agree with you Stephanie. I have seen Alex in all the movies you stated and I thought he was absolutely amazing in Tormented. Also, I would have to disagree with the negative comments regarding his acting ability and “lack of showing emotion.” I am not some sort of teenager drooling over his hotness, so I’m unaffected by that. I WAS moved by his performance in I am Number Four. In fact, I believe that not only did he do justice to the role, but he was much better than the character in the actual book.
I suppose it’s all a matter of taste. All the rest regarding his behaving like a “brat” or showing up late due to a house fire sounds like petty “He said, she said.” As a person who will pay money to see these films, I am concerned about him fitting the part. The fact that he was offered the role means that SOMEBODY who does this for a living (casting actors, that is), knows what they are doing. The rest is just nonsense.
March 28th, 2011 on 10:14 am
The original post fails to say that this was what was said about Pettyfer:
‘”Pick your words: ambitious, hungry, cocky, very ahead of himself,” says a producer who has worked with him. “But if he delivers, he’ll be worth it.”
And by many accounts, Pettyfer has mended his relationship with DreamWorks. The studio is developing a racing drama for him, and he has traveled to London, Miami and New York doing heavy promotion for Number Four, which premieres Wednesday night.
“He’s turned into a great partner,” says a DreamWorks exec.”’
I’m not interested in dating the guy. I’m interested in whether he can pull it off. Producers that have worked with him believe that he can. *shrugs*
April 4th, 2011 on 5:25 pm
I agree on Buffy’s posts. I just came from the cinema seeing ‘Ia#4′ for the ninth time and I’m very impressed by the entire cast DJ Caruso hired, and of course especially Alex Pettyfer’s impersonation of “Number Four”. I also was impressed by his other movies, especially on “Tom Brown’s Schooldays” and “Stormbreaker”. Although I wasn’t too happy about the “Stormbreaker” movie adaption from the novel i.e. the script, Alex Pettyfer created a fascinating impersonation of “Alex Rider 2.0”.
April 26th, 2011 on 1:12 am
I want to say this in a nice way you are wrong and stephanie is right I mean were not 100% sure that he want’s 10 million dollars. If we were one of his friends and knew that he did they sould go here right now like what I’m doing and tell the truth. I might not have liked any of the movies but what the heck doesn’t mean that he won’t be good in this movie. Besides we are not the director and we can’t change it. So let the director choose to have Alex Pettyfer instead of some random hot dude who hasen’t been in a movie since 2000 I mean I love the series 100% but I really people take the movie like it’s the part of their life but if it’s bad then don’t like it, if it’s good love it till you marry it.
March 25th, 2011 on 5:53 pm
Well Actually The Hollywood whatever its called is an actual newspaper and they were talking about Alex being an ass and everything else weve heard about.In my own opinion I think Max looks better for Jace than Alex.I agree that just because Alex’s last movies didnt do good doesnt mean hes a bad actor,but to me I think Max would be the better choice.Also there not gonna pick a Perfect Jace,because we all picture him differently in our minds.It was def a rumor,Im on Cassandra Clares google group called The_Mortal_instruments and she is always giving us any kind of news like Movie news,she let us know when Clary was casted and giving us updates on the Jace roll,she said They WILL continue if Alex isnt casted,she also gives us teasers for the upcoming books,You should join! As well as anyone else who hasnt yet! We have different discussions as well..But I also agree with saying he doesnt deserve it unless every rumor is true and if he really did ask for 10 million..
March 29th, 2011 on 12:31 pm
The Hollywood Reporter stopped being “an actual newspaper” some time ago. It is a glossy magazine peddling gossip. The quoted article followed none of the rules of good journalism.
May 29th, 2011 on 8:22 pm
I honestly agree with you.
Jesus christ people – sorry to say this. But most actors and actresses are horrible to their co-ctors, cast and set. Megan Fox compared Michael Bay to a nazi, and guess what, she’s not gonna be in the new Transformer movie, but hell, she’s still a really good actress.
Tons of actors out there are assholes, just like random people are assholes. And don’t believe what all magazines says, for gods sakes.
The Movie Industry is the movie industry, and let’s face it – it’s not about talent anymore, it’s about money. Good movies are usually movies that have a nice budget because of money, then they can produce a good movie, and then they can afford get decent-talented actors. It sucks, cause really the movie industry should focus more on talent, but no, it focus on money.
I think it’s great if Alex Pettyfer gets the role of Jace Wayland. I ask from nothing more of him then giving everything he has into playing that character – what he does behind the scenes – I could care less about, and so should people. It’s not any of their business. I’ve seen his movies, I liked them – personally I thought Vanessa Hudgens ruined Beastly.
Saying he doesn’t deserve the role is so wrong, cause you guys don’t have the rights to say he doesn’t deserve it! He’s probably a better human being than all of those people who are bashing his ass right now with dumb rumors that are created by stupid tabloids, or even better – you become just as bad as he is, if he even is like this.
I wish I could say us fans can pick the cast, but we can’t! If the director chooses Alex lets be happy about it. And who the hell came up with Alex asking for 10 million dollars for the part?
Alex Pettyfer seems to be a pretty popular option for the movie, and if the producers and directors are craving this much for him! It is then obviously a sign that he should get the part.
Teenagers these days.
July 15th, 2011 on 12:25 pm
Amen! Emma Watson got 30 million dollars for the last three HP movies and she’s the 3rd or 4th main chracter. Why should the actor who plays Jace make 10 million?
July 15th, 2011 on 12:30 pm
I mean, shouldn’t
March 20th, 2011 on 7:36 am
I agree. I hadn’t known about this, and i wasnt able to see I Am Number 4 because its not out in theaters here yet. i’m glad you wrote this, because it really makes you stop and think about what goes on behind closed doors. Attitude > Looks any day, imo. i dont need someone screwing up and being an elitist jerk throughout my favorite movies.
March 20th, 2011 on 7:58 am
I agree with absolutely everything that you have said! This time 2 months ago- i was desperate for him to be Jace. Now opposite-and for the exact same reasons that you have -and i couldnt have said it better!
March 20th, 2011 on 8:57 am
Ahhhh…
I dunno. Unless I hear (Charlie Sheen) or see (Charlie Sheen) a person truly acting the idiot, I never take any media outlet’s word for ANYTHING. This could be a PR campaign to get the actor into the news, hype the film, whatever. Or a personal problem like too many camera lenses in his face. I’d go nuts too if I was in that position.
I just don’t trust ‘unnamed sources’. I look at the media with a skewed eye and assume the best of Mr. Pettyfer.
March 22nd, 2011 on 9:30 am
The Hollywood Reporter is an actual newspaper. Had they printed “lies” about Alex then he could’ve sued for millions. The fact that Alex hasn’t sued says something (at least to me).
I’d like to say that my major issue with this is that Alex doesn’t seem excited about the role. He was offered it two months ago and here we still are in the same place. Most actors would chew off their own arm for the Jace role, but not Alex. He’s been very blah about it in interviews.
When Lily Collins signed on as Clary, she opened up a twitter account just for TMI fans. She talks to them all the time and has been very vocal with her excitement for the opportunity. Don’t you want someone with that same type of attitude as our Jace?
I’m not trying to change your mind here, the article was meant to give you something to think about.
March 25th, 2011 on 6:05 am
I think you are wrong with your position on suing the press. If Alex would sue every paper telling something wrong about him he probably would need one or two office floors full of lawyers, and I think he knows that this wouldn’t exactly improve his reputation as an actor if he was in the headlines every week with law sues.
I personally think for example that it was an impertinence by the press which seriously breaches his right of privacy to publish his full address in February in papers and on the internet.
March 25th, 2011 on 10:15 am
Stacey is right; if a newspaper prints something that is false, Alex can sue. I have a bachelors degree in journalism and believe me, we studied this in depth. It’s the Defamation, Libel and Slander law. Defamation is the issuance of a false statement about another person, which causes that person to suffer harm. Slander is the making of defamatory statements by a transitory representation. Libel involves the making of defamatory statements in a printed or fixed medium, such as a magazine or newspaper (i.e. The Hollywood Reporter). So yes, Stacey, I’m with you; he hasn’t sued because nothing was false. People are quick to defend their name.
And thank you for posting this! The Mortal Instruments is my favorite series, and we NEED someone who cares and is passionate.
March 25th, 2011 on 3:52 pm
@Courtney
Alongside other subjects I studied civil and commercial law and I totally agree to you and Stacey that Alex could sue not only the Hollywood Reporter but hundreds of papers around the world when they say something untrue. The same applies to thousands of commenters with hate mails and lies.
But if he would do that, he wouldn’t be able to concentrate on his work as an actor but would become famous and making headlines for suing other people. And he could definitely do that for the press publishing his private address worldwide, which may cause fans besiege his home but also could be a security problem. And Zac Efron could probably sue the press for saying he is gay.
But most celebs don’t want to become famous by holding the world record on lawsuits, because that would give them a bad press and a bad reputation, and would distract them from work.
And Alex Pettyfer has been saying for years that he never ever checks what people write about him on the internet, because the lies would make him mad and distract him from his work and his life. Therefore he never googles himself on the internet and tries to avoid all stories about himself as good as he can.
I could now start discussing with you that the conclusion you and Stacey draw from the fact that he is not suing is wrong, based on mathematical propositional logic, the rules of scientific proofs and the procedural method to write a juridical expertise, but I think that would unnecessarily inflate the discussion. I thought I already had made my point clear with my last contribution above, but I hope you understand my point now.
March 29th, 2011 on 12:43 pm
All of these people who are claiming that Alex would sue if the stories written about him are false fail to understand basic libel laws, and that includes the person with a coveted B.A. in journalism. It is almost impossible to win a libel suit in the USA because you have to show two things: 1) that the article is wrong, and 2) that the article was written with the intent of malice. So even if you can show beyond a reasonable doubt that someone is writing lies about you it is much harder, almost impossible, to show malicious intent. That’s why libel suits in the USA are so few and far between. It is not logical at all to suggest that everything written about Alex Pettyfer is true because he hasn’t sued.
March 20th, 2011 on 9:23 am
I saw Beastly just to see if he would be able to do Jace some semblance of justice, because he seemed like the main contender – he was the only name I really saw, so I wanted to be sure it wasn’t going to go the way of Twilight – and thought he COULD do it if he’s going to. But if he’s a brat I’d rather he go to some other film, one that DOESN’T have so many people who are so deeply invested.
March 20th, 2011 on 9:34 am
COULD meaning he would be better than Robert Pattinson and Kristen Stewart’s efforts at Edward and Bella. That is my comparison point, because that was a study in UTTER CASTING FAILURE.
March 20th, 2011 on 1:17 pm
Oh. My. God.
Thank you SO much for publishing this! My thoughts EXACTLY! I’m so tired of the fandom just wanting Pettyfer because he looks the part, without really knowing what that would mean for the series. His attitude problem and obviously poor acting (as seen from the reviews of his 2 latest movies) would probably mean the ending of the movie adaptions after City Of Bones. I would love someone unknown – I really hope the producers realize this, or it will be a major fail, and just an embarrasment for the TMI fandom.
March 29th, 2011 on 12:47 pm
Have you actually seen these performances that you are denegrating or are you just a sheep that believes everything you read? Perhaps instead of worrying about Alex Pettyfer’s potential performance ruining the TMI movies, you should worry about the fact that they are being made by a two-bit studio by a fourth-rate director.
March 20th, 2011 on 2:24 pm
Wow! This post made me change my plans to se Pettyfer’s upcoming movie Beastly, and instead see Red Riding Hood. I try not to get to invested in these sorts of things, but I must say, I totally agree with you. It certainly seems Max is the better contender to play my personal heartthrob Jace. Plus his attitude and acting is much better and personaly more attracting to that of Pettyfer’s!
Max is also much hotter than Alex, hello Alez ISN’T THAT HOT! But Max on the other hand, I could see playing Cassandra Clare’s Jace. She deserves more than some kid fresh with emotional and obvious attitude/ personal problems. If Alex does choose to play Jace then he definitely needs to get some personal things worked out and in order before even contemplating screwing up the role of JAce!!!
Max Irons has my vote, actually anyone BUT Pettyfer has my vote!
March 20th, 2011 on 4:59 pm
A lot of bull! I’m still on Pettyfer!
March 22nd, 2011 on 9:33 am
The Hollywood Reporter is an actual newspaper. They write only what they can back up. They aren’t trash like Star for example which means that Alex could sue them for millions if they printed a bunch of crap.
I’m not trying to change your mind here, but you have to consider that.
March 20th, 2011 on 5:44 pm
Well, sorry if I have a different opinion.
First of all most of the stories about Alex Pettyfer are made up by the tabloid press and don’t refer to reality in any way.
Yes, Alex had a severe argument with DJ Caruso in summer about the payment issue. But I wouldn’t be happy if I found out that a co-worker gets more money for less work either. However, if you have seen DJ Caruso and Alex Pettyfer within the last months you probably had the impression that they don’t have any hard feelings with each other and they harmonize perfectly and making jokes. I mean, even in a family sometimes there is an argument, but that’s no problem in the long run.
Oh yes, Alex Pettyfer was late on two occasions. Of course, none of you ever has been late in your life, have you ?
If you add up all the times Alex Pettyfer was late, it is still much less than the amount of time Paris Hilton is late on one occasion sometimes.
And all other stories have been invented by the tabloid press. So why should I change my opinion on Alex Pettyfer. I still want him to play Jace Wayland !
And if you change your opinion after every idiotic article you read in the tabloid press perhaps you should ask yourself if you have any opinion at all !?!?
March 20th, 2011 on 6:53 pm
First, thank you for your opinion. I am aware that not everyone will agree with me so I’ve posted all responses that came in whether positive or not.
Regarding your comments…
Getting into an argument with a director and wanting a new salary because someone is paid more than you is just immature and unprofessional. The other actor was paid more because he had more actor creds and was more famous. It doesn’t matter how many lines you have. An A list actor could be paid a million dollars to have a cameo in a movie. Call it what you want, but he’s shown nothing but a piss poor attitude. Your director is your boss and cannot be compared to an argument with your family. If a CEO had to get involved then it was very serious. Being two hours late to a meeting without calling is unprofessional. Part of your payment as an actor is to promote and he needed to be there for the Beastly team. Can’t you see a patter here, really?
The ten million dollar demand for City of Bones wasn’t made up. It’s just about a kid who’s trying to get the most out of a situation because he’s the fan favorite.
I would much rather see an unknown come in who’s passionate about the role and not his paycheck. Someone like Lily Collins, who after signing on as Clary, created a special twitter account for TMI fans. She regularly chats with fans and has great enthusiam for the project. That’s what I’d like to see from the actor selected as Jace.
March 21st, 2011 on 1:02 pm
YES! Someone like LILY COLLINS. She’s great for the role, kind, has a good attitude and shows interest in her role, the books, and fans.
March 24th, 2011 on 8:46 pm
Stacy, I didn’t say that Alex Pettyfer is perfect as a person. He might have a bad temper sometimes like most people, He doesn’t have too much experience with the business side of the movie business since “I am Number Four” was only his sixth movie, and since he was fourteen when he started his career his mother took care of the business side. So, how can you expect him to act professionally on business questions without any experience ? He is only 20 and I’m sure he will learn if he gets the opportunity. If you say he doesn’t deserve to work as an actor, how should he learn ?
The same thing is with his idea of the payment for future movie projects. He has to learn to realistically evaluate the amount of money he can ask for. And I guess he already might have had some second thoughts about that after seeing the box office results of his last movies. But this is a learning process which requires experience, too.
On the other hand we are living in market economy, where everybody from dishwasher to CEO is trying to maximize his income. If Alex Pettyfer wouldn’t try to do that, I would call him an idiot. That is professionalism, too. Like all other professions actors work for there livelihood. That doesn’t make any indication of the passion of an actor. And these are all things which he can learn and improve during his career. And all those points are not affecting his on screen performance in any way.
About his reliability I might agree to you if you had the facts right. First of all as far as I know it is not the rule that Alex Pettyfer is late or doesn’t show up, it’s the exception to the rule. But I think you are also mistaken about him not calling, since a CBS Films Rep is quoted (article of Febuary 9th) by “Hollywood Reporter” and other sources that he DID call and explained that he was having car trouble.
I had my own bad luck with Alex Pettyfer when I was invited to meet him and get an autograph. I was happy, traveled hundreds of miles and waited about 90 minutes when Teresa (Palmer) told me that he “was sick” and wouldn’t show up. So I had to do small talk with Teresa and DJ Caruso instead of getting an autograph and perhaps a question answered by AP. As usual, the press had different stories about the reason (bad tooth, bad cold, and so on).
Fortunately there’s television and video to allow me to find out the truth myself. It turned out that Alex Pettyfer traveled thousands of miles to be present at the presentation and arrived (very early) even one day before, giving some TV-Interviews. But in an interview he gave earlier the same day you could clearly see that he didn’t feel to well. During the interview he had a hard burst of sneezing with DJ Caruso commenting ”That’s one of his superpowers”. And even so it was a weekend which was a little frustrating and I wasted much more time than the CBS Films people, for me he obviously did his best to show up, and even an actor can get ill. Therefore though I had bad luck I try to be fair to other people and still think Alex Pettyfer is a reliable person.
And I don’t think the question is what Alex Pettyfer deserves. The question is whether the fans deserve to have the actor they originally wanted before other people started to manipulate the fan’s opinions by discrediting Alex Pettyfer.
March 20th, 2011 on 8:18 pm
I agree with you. I mean, what if he arrived late at the premiere?? Jeez, it’s not as if he was driving drunk like Christina Aguilera or was caught smoking marijuana like Miley Cyrus. The tabloids have to stop.
March 24th, 2011 on 11:49 pm
“The question is whether the fans deserve to have the actor they originally wanted before other people started to manipulate the fan’s opinions by discrediting Alex Pettyfer.”
But you’re not a fan. You’ve already stated you won’t see the movie if Alex Pettyfer isn’t in it, even though the only person preventing Alex Pettyfer from being in the movie is Alex Pettyfer. That’s not the behavior of a fan of the books, or someone who has any respect for them or the people who love them at all. Please, don’t act like you speak for me or any other fans.
March 25th, 2011 on 4:23 pm
@Angela
No, you got me wrong. In fact I am a fan of the book. But I hope you don’t force me to like the movie because I like the books. These are different things.
Normally of course I’d love the movie. But I’m displeased
a) with the fact that Alex Pettyfer and Clint Culpepper didn’t reach an agreement in January.
b) that Clint Culpepper announced something he wasn’t prepared to keep
c) that he is obviously launching press stories to change the fan’s opinions and solve the problem he constructed himself with his earlier statement.
The motivation not to see the movie is that I am annoyed by the turn the pre-production took, and if somebody else plays Jace, that will remind me to the facts I am angry about. And when I pay for a cinema ticket I want to enjoy the movie and not to be reminded to facts that make me angry.
July 15th, 2011 on 12:37 pm
I know! big deal! Everybody comes in late sometimes. Alex’ mistakes are just magnified because he’s famous.
March 25th, 2011 on 5:35 pm
“No, you got me wrong. In fact I am a fan of the book. But I hope you don’t force me to like the movie because I like the books. These are different things. Normally of course I’d love the movie.”
Normally I wouldn’t call you not a fan of the books because you refuse to see the movie. Book fans can have all sorts of good reasons for not seeing a movie adaptation of books they like. But your reasons are insane. Like actually cloud-cuckoo-land-lost-your-mind-I-hope-to-God-you-get-on-medication insane.
” But I’m displeased
a) with the fact that Alex Pettyfer and Clint Culpepper didn’t reach an agreement in January.”
Which is a reason to punish the movie franchise because? Every piece of available evidence points to the lack of reaching an agreement in January as being Alex’s fault.
“b) that Clint Culpepper announced something he wasn’t prepared to keep”
Is this the “he won’t make the movie without Alex Pettyfer” drum you keep whacking on? There is no evidence he ever actually said this. He has said he never said it. Cassandra has said he never said it. In interviews, Alex has seemed shocked to hear that it was claimed Culpepper ever said it. Nor would any genuine fan of the books ever have wanted him to have said it. Yet you can’t let it go.
” that he is obviously launching press stories to change the fan’s opinions and solve the problem he constructed himself with his earlier statement.”
This is wild-eyed bullshit that you made up. You have no evidence that this is the case, and everything you have presented as evidence is not even wild stories in the tabloid press: it’s your paranoid interpretation of those wild stories. The reports of Alex’s bad on set behavior have been sourced to Dreamworks and CBS, how does that have anything to do with Culpepper? I suppose you think he set fire to Alex’s house and paid off Dianna Agron to dump him too?
“The motivation not to see the movie is that I am annoyed by the turn the pre-production took, and if somebody else plays Jace, that will remind me to the facts I am angry about. And when I pay for a cinema ticket I want to enjoy the movie and not to be reminded to facts that make me angry.”
As someone else said earlier, I don’t think the filmmakers are going to be too worried about not selling tickets to the lunatic fringe element. I think we’re done here, as you are actually starting to scare me, and from what I can tell, everyone else too. You have done an excellent job of convincing me that Alex Pettyfer really is an asshole, FWIW, so congrats.
March 27th, 2011 on 7:35 pm
@angela
Hey,
just because you don’t agree does not make it right to say that other peoples motivations are insane.
I love the books, and thought that Alex would be perfect for the role.
I get why some of you are ready to back out and go to other actors but thomasd5 just said what was on her(?) mind.
Once an actor is “wanted”, dirt is written. Whether it’s true or not is up to interpretation. I give him the benefit of the doubt. if you don’t, it’s okay. But don,t jump ship because a few article.
The money issue may be it (still not convinced). But what would you do if 3 great projects would be offered to you? (I know I would take my sweet ass making my mind up)
I just hate that if you still want him as Jace, people start bashing. Please don’t. it will not help the situation or change it. Whatever happens, the actor that willl play Jace will not be good enought for everybody.
and ps. the movie is not made yet… we are all fans otherwise we would not be here.
March 20th, 2011 on 6:29 pm
I use to be a die hard “Alex for Jace” fan, because of his physical resemblance to Jace, but his apparent lack of interest in playing this roll has done it for me. I think whoever gets to play Jace should be someone who would jump at the chance of doing it, because Jace is a really cool character and TMI series is amazing
March 20th, 2011 on 9:44 pm
Jeremy Irons has a son? Then, I vote for him and Jeremy as Valentine would totally rock. But I also agree with Viriginia in that anyone who isn’t jumping at the chance to play Jace is the wrong person for the role.
March 25th, 2011 on 12:08 am
I love the idea of Jeremy Irons playing Valentine if Max is Jace….
July 15th, 2011 on 12:40 pm
Max would be better as Sebastian then, wouldn’t he?
March 20th, 2011 on 9:45 pm
I agree with you!
Demanding 10 million dollars is ridiculous and it’s only because fans are dying to have him on board. he doesn’t seem to be interested in the role I want someone who is enthusiastic for the part. I’m all about max irons for jace from now on.
March 21st, 2011 on 1:00 pm
A-freaking-men times two. No one with that kind of attitude deserves to play one of the protagonists in the adaption of an amazing novel. Couldn’t have said it better.
March 21st, 2011 on 2:09 pm
I think Max Irons is too old for the role and I don’t think he has the right look. I liked him in Red Riding Hood and think he did a great job of creating screen presence and charisma. Actually, I still think Amanda S.’s character should have chosen his character over that other one, lol. But I’m not sold on him for Jace. AP looked right for the part, but that was two years ago. He also has the right kind of cocky, arrogant attitude as Jace, he’s just missing the softer, passionate, romantic side.
In short, I have no suggestion for the role. I’ve seen some suggestions that I can’t get behind at all, such as the guy from Eragon and this other guy (Josh maybe?) who looks way too feminine. Some look promising, such as Alexander Nifong, but it’s hard to say if his attitude is right, because he has had such little screen time.
I’m just ready for a decision to be made. This is a wonderfully engaging series. The male romantic hero that Cassie Clare created is irresistable and one of the best to come along in ages. Its a role that will put some young man on the map. I agree that whoever that young man is, he should be aware of the importance of the role, how cool the character is, and should show the proper enthusiasm for the role.
Alex Pettyfer probably does want a hefty paycheck. I think he should be realistic and realize that huge demands can only be made by those with a proven track record in Hollywood, and then only as long as they are proven to be box office draws. Of course, this series has the potential to be huge and make a lot of people very wealthy, and whoever plays Jace would be part of the reason for that success. HOWEVER, the success has not yet been shown and neither has AP’s ability to put people in seats at the theatre. He should check his ego, at least until he has something to actually show for himself. Yes, it might sting a little, to see others making big profits while he takes in a small salary. BUT, if the series is successful he could use it to receive the roles he wants and demand the salary he derserves. But, as you said, that requires some maturity.
I also think he’s waiting to see if he’s cast in the Hunger Games movies. Again, if the actor offered the role of Jace isn’t enthusiastic about it, maybe he shouldn’t take it. Maybe he isn’t right for it. That’s the part that really chaps my a**. He knows the potential for fan adoration, the incredible amount of support shown to him (a complete unknown when the fan campaign for him first began), and he is completely unmoved. He should, out of decency, acknowledge the fans’s efforts on HIS behalf, all the clamoring they have done, and all that their enthusiasm has done for his career, by at least addressing them and making his intentions regarding the role of Jace known.
Personally, I think if he turns down the role at this point, the huge fandom that had been in his corner (in anticipation of him taking on the role of Jace) will become annoyed and the enormous goodwill they’d shown him will probably turn negative.
March 21st, 2011 on 7:48 pm
I totally agree! I want someone who’s enthusiastic about the role to play Jace, not someone just focused on the money. It’s obvious that Lily Collins is happy about being Clary; she interacts with fans, she set up a twitter account specifically for TMI fans, etc. That shows me that she is dedicated. And it seems that Pettyfer is not interested in playing Jace. And his attitude makes me like him even less. I’m disappointed too, because a few months ago I thought he’d be perfect for the part. Not anymore, however.
March 22nd, 2011 on 12:07 am
AP is unproven. He doesnt even seem to be excited to be offered the role. And he has no right to demand anything.
March 22nd, 2011 on 4:08 pm
I have seen ” I Am Number Four” and “Beastly”. I was not impressed with AP’s acting at all. I am also not impressed with his attitude about MI. Maybe he is to comfortable with the fact that fans have been saying he is Jace for so long that he assumes that it is a done deal as far as we are concerned. He may have the look for Jace, but I agree with everyone else having the look is not enough and I don’t think he has what it takes to bring this character to life. He shouldn’t get this part. He doesn’t have the passion for the series, the character or the fans that he should. I hope that the studio listens to the fans and moves on to someone more deserving of the role. I like Max Irons but am open to other actors. All that being said I hope he stays away from the “Hunger Games” movie too.
March 23rd, 2011 on 3:45 am
So, what is the opinion of the fans ? My opinion has been for a long time that Alex Pettyfer from my point of view is the only perfect Jace. I have also seen the four Alex-Pettyfer-movies released prior to Ia#4 and “Beastly” and I’ve no reason at all to change my mind. Obviously people have different opinions on Ia#4 and “Beastly”. Some peoply liked Alex’s work, others like you didn’t. But you don’t know too much about Alex Pettyfer’s attitude about TMI since you only read what other people wrote about it. That is not reliable information.
But if you see the discussion on other web pages you might find out that still a lot of fans want him to play Jace, while the comments on this page seem to indicate that some people not only change their shirts periodical but also their opinion. If Screen Gems follows these opinions that won’t help because those people might change their minds again several times during the production process.
As you might know, the idea of Alex Pettyfer being the perfect Jace started a long time ago in the first half of 2008, when there was no “Beastly”, “I Am Number Four” and no serious idea of adapting the book into a movie.
At that time some “Mortal Instruments”-fans started putting self-made “Clary and Jace”-Trailers on video portals with Alex Pettyfer as Jace and were discussing Alex Pettyfer being the perfect Jace.
And like me many other fans of “The Mortal Instruments” I didn’t find out about the book series by an advertisement or because somebody told me. No, I permanently hit videos or messages on the Internet suggesting that Alex Pettyfer exactly looks like Jace. In the beginning I thought “The Mortal Instruments” must be some kind of fan-fiction. But when I repeatedly hit “Mortal Instruments” messages and video trailers with Alex looking like Jace, I got curious, found out that it is a series of novels and opened my first TMI book, of course with the idea on my mind that Jace looks like Alex. And that is a way, many fans have learned about the books, while others already knew the books getting the idea of Alex looking like Jace from the videos or forum pages.
Anyways, this is a process going on for three years now with people opening their first TMI book with that idea on their minds. And that is the reason why in the vision of many TMI-fans it is very deep-rooted that Alex is the perfect Jace.
And I promise you, if he doesn’t play Jace, I will never ever see any TMI-movie at the cinema. Since I usually go to a movie several times and take quite some friends with me, this means 12 to 20 tickets less sold per TMI-movie at the Box office. And no horror story in the tabloid press will change my opinion about Alex being the perfect Jace.
March 23rd, 2011 on 3:25 pm
“But you don’t know too much about Alex Pettyfer’s attitude about TMI since you only read what other people wrote about it. That is not reliable information.”
She read what newspapers wrote about it. That’s actually very reliable information. The Hollywood Reporter is not a tabloid. It’s a well-respected film industry trade publication. If they printed bald lies they’d be sued.
“And I promise you, if he doesn’t play Jace, I will never ever see any TMI-movie at the cinema. Since I usually go to a movie several times and take quite some friends with me, this means 12 to 20 tickets less sold per TMI-movie at the Box office.”
No exec is going to be boo hooing over twenty tickets less sold. Especially for such an insane reason. You clearly don’t care about the books or the quality of the film – you only care about seeing a vehicle for Alex Pettyfer. Since there aren’t very many of you (or he’d be a more marketable actor) Thank God, don’t let the door hit your ass on the way out of the TMI fandom, since you clearly couldn’t give a shit about these books anyway.
March 23rd, 2011 on 3:28 pm
Also — Alex Pettyfer got offered the role. So if he turns it down, you’re going to punish the whole franchise by refusing to see any of the films? That makes sense how?
March 23rd, 2011 on 4:23 pm
Half of the fandom wants alex for jace because he looks like him, they don’t care whether he has any acting chops or not. just like the tabloids say, Alex pettyfer is all hype no hits. his movies under performed in the box office and critics weren’t too happy with his acting ability either. what really upsets me is that, your not going to see the movie because alex isn’t playing jace it shows that you’re a bigger alex pettyfer fan then mortal instruments, I guess that’s how fans show defiance when things doesn’t go their way.
July 15th, 2011 on 12:42 pm
Amen to that. I didn’t think Alex sucked for either Beastly or I am Number 4. Alex is the only one who can play Jace in my opinion.
March 23rd, 2011 on 8:15 am
Do we really need someone to be Jace just because of his looks and not the acting talent? And seriously, he’e been under-performing for all the movies that he’s been in….and I don’t want that.
March 23rd, 2011 on 8:58 pm
Well said. I really wish that it was so, but I don’t want someone in the part of Jace who is going to kill good cast vibes and be a primadonna. I am SOO Team Max Irons right now!!!
March 24th, 2011 on 8:57 pm
@Ruby
Ruby, thank you for finally giving me the key to reality. I always thought Dianna Agron and Alex Pettyfer respectively their Reps denied the engagement rumors because they were not engaged. Your contribution made me realize that they were engaged all the time but they didn’t know that at all because Hollywood Reporter forgot to inform them about there engagement by sending them a copy of that article !
The same thing with the interviews he gave together with DJ Caruso in fall, with both of them making jokes. Make up your own mind whether that is an actor who according to “Hollywood Reporter” was “in protest mode” until the middle of December! Perhaps you should use your own perception instead of believing in such stories !
And I’m not interested in vehicles for Alex Pettyfer. Like most fans I wanted Alex Pettyfer to play Jace last December. But in contradiction to most of you, I keep my opinion and do not allow peopele like Clint Culpepper and the tabloid press to manipulate and remote control it by discrediting Alex Pettyfer. And this has nothing to do with me being a fan of the books. But for me the movie production is unnerving because the people involved were unable to agree in January. And why should I pay for cinema tickets if I’m already displeased with the production before the shooting of the movie even starts ?
@all
You, and with you I mean all the people commenting on this page, should reflect a little bit on the “news” you are hearing and reading. If you compare the news you get for example from Rupert Murdoch’s media group to the New York Times you will find a total different view on the world in both medias, even if we assume all news are correct. But you can manipulate news by
a) the selection,
b) by the place (front page or hidden in the middle) and
c) size you are giving it,
d) and by the depiction you are giving it, which might make the actions of the subjects more ore less reasonable.
e) In addition at least in the tabloid press you have made up stories, which are either are totally invented or an unimportant fact is inflated to a drama or scandal.
f) Additionally there are “Spin-Doctors”, people outside the press that launch stories and selected information in order to turn the public opinion for their advantage, and are often very successful.
And as far as the Jace casting is concerned, all of this methods have been used by the book and successfully changed the opinion of many fans, which last December wanted Alex Pettyfer and now want somebody else although the qualities of Alex Pettyfer as an actor didn’t decrease while those of other actors didn’t improve significantly during that period.
And if you think, who might have a motivation to act as a spin doctor on the Jace casting, I can give you one: Clint Culpepper, the president of Sony Screen Gems, who is the studio boss of TMI production. In January he announced that he would “not green-light” the “City of Bones” movie unless Alex Pettyfer signs as “Jace” and the result of the negotiations should be announced at the beginning of the following week. But the negotiations were not that successful, maybe because Alex Pettyfer has no experience in what amount of money he realistically can ask for. But obviously Mr. Culpepper wasn’t serious with what he said (not to green-light the movioe), and so he had to find an other solution. And the option left was to change the Fan’s opinions for their favorite Jace actor by discrediting Alex Pettyfer. That is for example the reason why a story was launched that Alex Pettyfer was asking for almost ten million Dollars.
And most of you fans on this page obviously allowed others to manipulate your opinion without even realizing that.
March 24th, 2011 on 9:15 pm
sorry for the typos! @Ruby I meant: ….Hollywood Reporter forgot to inform them about THEIR engagement…
March 25th, 2011 on 2:43 pm
“Ruby, thank you for finally giving me the key to reality. I always thought Dianna Agron and Alex Pettyfer respectively their Reps denied the engagement rumors because they were not engaged. Your contribution made me realize that they were engaged all the time but they didn’t know that at all because Hollywood Reporter forgot to inform them about there engagement by sending them a copy of that article !”
I am impressed with your ability to write an entire paragraph that makes no sense at all. It’s barely English.
“And I’m not interested in vehicles for Alex Pettyfer. Like most fans I wanted Alex Pettyfer to play Jace last December. But in contradiction to most of you, I keep my opinion and do not allow peopele like Clint Culpepper and the tabloid press to manipulate and remote control it by discrediting Alex Pettyfer.”
A lot of fans wanted Alex Pettyfer to play Jace last December. The idea that they’ve changed their minds because of “made up tabloid rumors” (apparently nothing gets through your lead-lined brain, not even the fact that The Hollywood Reporter isn’t a tabloid, and that libel laws exist) is one you invented. Yes, no one is really all that impressed by his reported behavior, but the main difference between December and now is that his two much-hyped movies came out AND WE ACTUALLY SAW THEM. They sucked, and he sucked in them. They were both flops. He has gone from being an unknown quantity to a known lousy one.
“And if you think, who might have a motivation to act as a spin doctor on the Jace casting, I can give you one: Clint Culpepper, the president of Sony Screen Gems, who is the studio boss of TMI production. In January he announced that he would “not green-light” the “City of Bones” movie unless Alex Pettyfer signs as “Jace” and the result of the negotiations should be announced at the beginning of the following week. But the negotiations were not that successful, maybe because Alex Pettyfer has no experience in what amount of money he realistically can ask for. But obviously Mr. Culpepper wasn’t serious with what he said (not to green-light the movioe), and so he had to find an other solution.”
While it is very difficult to argue with someone so clearly wearing an enormous tinfoil hat, let’s point out a few things:
If you refuse to believe anything written in the “tabloid press”, or in fact any press or media outlet at all, then you have not a leg to stand on in asserting that Clint Culpepper ever said he wouldn’t make the movie without Alex. Either you believe the press or not, you can’t cherry-pick what you want to believe. Especially considering that that rumor originated in Vulture, which actually is a gossip blog, not a newspaper. And especially considering that no studio boss in the process of negotiations would say a thing like that. It cuts the legs out from under his negotiating power. The only person that is benefited by a rumor like that being spread is Alex. Wake up.
March 26th, 2011 on 7:24 am
@Ruby
Ruby, sorry for not explaining my position in the first paragraph clearly. I try to rephrase it:
According to some people in this discussion everything written in the “Hollywood Reporter” is absolutely true. However, for example they reported the engagement between Dianna Agron and Alex Pettyfer, which was untrue. They also reported that Alex Pettyfer was in “protest mode” until December after a severe clash with DJ Caruso in summer. But the fact that they were perfectly harmonic in interviews and joking relaxed clearly indicates that Alex Pettyfer wasn’t in “protest mode” at all, which means again the “Hollywood Reporter” was wrong. And a magazine that quite often reports wrong facts in my opinion is not very reliable.
And obviously the libel laws do not effectively prevent rumors and false information since libel laws apply to the tabloid press, too.
About his latest movies, for example IA#4: If reviewers say there are no really new ideas in the novel and most of the plot is a combination of ideas borrowed from other books, movies and TV shows, I totally agree to that. Although the story is not not that bad. But it is difficult to adapt the book into a movie because the plot in the book is permanently and unnervingly interrupted by lengthy flashbacks. Therefore I think DJ Caruso and the scriptwriters did an excellent job by not interrupting the plot with any flashbacks and trying to give the audience the required information in other form. And he did a very good casting job with the complete cast. The only point I have to agree to reviewers is that Dianna Agron always seems to have the same facial expression during the entire movie, which becomes a little unnerving. Anyway, I pre-ordered the novel last year, and after reading it from my point of view the movie was pretty much what I had expected.
And if anybody tells me he/she doesn’t like AP’s face or chin, I can accept that. If anyone tells me he/she doesn’t like Alex Pettyfer’s performances on movies I can accept that, too. But if anybody tells me he/she liked AP’s performance in his first four movies but not the ones in the latest two, I do have to admit, that I have problems in understanding that since he didn’t change his performance notably. I mean after seeing his first four movies his performance in the new movies for me was exactly as expected. Or did anybody notice any relevant change in the way he is performing his roles ?
“And especially considering that no studio boss in the process of negotiations would say a thing like that”
OK, I can see the point that it wouldn’t be wise for a studio boss to issue such a statement, although on the other hand I don’t think that Alex Pettyfer has the connections to launch such a story. But I’ve to agree that there is a chance that this was made up by Vulture, though if it is untrue I would have expected Screen Gems to disclaim the story in order not to corrupt their negotiating position.
But the details of the negotiations were only known by two parties: Alex Pettyfer and his Reps on one side and Clint Culpepper and a few people of his staff on the other side. Therefore the story launched after the negotiations clearly came from Screen Gems if the facts reported in the story are true.
March 24th, 2011 on 11:54 pm
How do you know all this? you refuse to believe AP has an attitude problem but your saying clint culpepper is discrediting alex on purpose so fans hate him, without any logical explanations? you know what I think? i think your just trying to defend AP by blaming someone else!
July 15th, 2011 on 12:45 pm
OmG! I’m on my sister’s account, but my name is Amelia too!
March 25th, 2011 on 12:05 am
do you realize how much of a hypocrite you are?? here you’re saying we shouldn’t believe whatever cr*p is being published about AP but your doing the same thing with clint culpepper. except, I think this is based on your wild imagination then tabloid stories.
March 26th, 2011 on 7:58 am
@amelia & jasmin
As I pointed out above, if the facts reported from the negotiations are true, only a few people knew those details. Since Alex Pettyfer and his Reps wouldn’t discredit themselves, that information could only have been launched by Screen Gems. And Mr. Culpepper doesn’t have the intention to make Alex Pettyfer’s “fans hate him”. Studios are not interested in fans hating any actor, since maybe some years later they might exactly cast that actor for any other movie.
The negotiations with the fan favorite didn’t turn out the way Screen Gems expected, therefore the best way for Screen Gems to solve the problem is to make fans change their favorite for impersonating Jace. In that case they don’t have to continue difficult negotiations and can even so fulfill the fans wishes by influencing those.
And this is not based on “wild imagination” or “without any logical explanation” since the facts speak for themselves because only few people knew details from the negotiations.
July 15th, 2011 on 12:44 pm
I agree.
March 24th, 2011 on 10:21 pm
Oh. My. God. This is just getting way too crazy and bloody in here. Look, I don’t want Alex Pettyfer to be Jace because I don’t think he can act. I haven’t read “tabloids” or newspapers about his behavior off-screen, but his on-screen behavior leaves A LOT to be desired. And really, when has a movie whose hype is actor-orientated EVER been good? Ella Enchanted had Hugh Dancy and Anne Hathaway as the marketing vehicle, and that movie was a disaster in every way, shape, and form. Movies marketed on the merits of the book, like all three Lord of the Rings films and all three Narnia films, as well as the Harry Potter series, are much bigger hits–Return of the King won 11 Oscars, and Voyage of the Dawn Treader has already made about $300 million worldwide (don’t quote me on that–it’s just the last number I remember hearing after Japan’s earthquake disasters). If you’re going to watch a movie based on this actor or that actress in the lead role, you’re already going for the wrong reason.
And food for thought for all you Alex Pettyfer fans out there: if he’s truly eager and whole-hearted about bringing Jace to life on the screen, then why in Raziel’s name is he taking so long to accept the part?
July 15th, 2011 on 12:48 pm
I agree with you. I’m Elisa’s sister if you’re wondering why im contradicting myself. Some movies were failures even though the books were good (like twilight) but good books usually turn into good movies.
March 24th, 2011 on 11:01 pm
I don’t want to get into this debate to much, but as for fans wanting AP for Jace as early as 2008 and are now changing their minds; perhaps this is because they have now seen AP is some major blockbusters and were not satisfied. I was all for AP for Jace, but I did not like him in Beastly I thought he lacked depth. I read Beastly and knew what the character of Kyle was supposed to be like. I’ve also read I am Number Four and am leery about the movie. At this point I don’t think AP would be suitable as Jace.
March 25th, 2011 on 5:38 am
When I read all the statements on this page, there are many points that I might agree with by seeing it from my point of view only. But if I make up my mind what I expect from other people, I should try to see things from their point of view, too.
One thing said above was that Alex Pettyfer obviously doesn’t appreciate the fan movement that sees him Jace for years. But, does he know ? Who told him ? As far as I know, he didn’t know about TMI at all since he was approached by the director of “City of Bones” (I think on December 10th) last year and he read the books end of December over the holidays for the first time. You could argue that though MTV didn’t tell him about the fan movement they told him that a lot of fans wanted him to play Jace.
But look at the things from his point of view. Within the last month at least seven movie projects approached him, and of course all of these projects have fans who want him to play that role. And we don’t know if he even has been approached by other movie projects which might have contacted him silently without informing the press. The seven projects I know of are:
1. TMI [Fantasy]
2. The Hunger Games [Fantasy]
3. The Seventh Son (Wardstone Chronicles / The Spooks (last) Apprentice) [Fantasy]
4. The Paperboy [Thriller]
5.The Bourne Legacy [Thriller]
6. Preacher [Comic Adaption]
7. Shunt – The Story of James Hunt [Biopic]
(and there may be other projects we don’t know of)
So he has a lot to decide, and the usual way of a decision process is to talk to the director, read the script (and the novel if it is a book adaption), to check the calendar, look at the intended cast and make up his mind whether the role/character is attractive for him.
He agreed on the biopic, which is actually his project, but that shouldn’t be a problem since I guess it will be in pre-production for quite some time.
He passed on “The Seventh Son” although they had an attractive cast (Jeff Bridges/Julianne Moore) and wanted him so desperately that they even were prepared to adapt the age of the main character from twelve to his age.
The Bourne Legacy people have a long list of candidates for the lead so the chances for Alex Pettyfer won’t be too big to play lead there.
On “The Paperboy” and “Preacher” he seems to be the only candidate for a main role / lead. And on TMI and “The Hunger Games” there are obviously several candidates.
And it is Alex Pettyfer’s problem to find the right one out of these four plus unknown offers.
And of course from my point of view like many other fans I want him to prefer TMI, but from his point of view there are some rival movie projects where he is on the list for a main role, and all of these projects have their fans wanting him to play that role.
So, when a lot of you missing his passion for TMI the reason is that he hasn’t decided yet, and he can’t play all of them. So let him decide first and then show the passion for the specific role he has chosen.
And apart from being unable to show passion before even the decision is done, many of you discussed about an actor has to twitter to the fans. But people are different. Yes, Justin Bieber and Lilly Collins (who already chose her movie project) use twitter, but other people are not that much into telecommunication and want to have a real life instead. I can understand that because as years going by, the amount of daily emails in my inbox is increasing and making me sort of a telecommunication slave. And Alex Pettyfer doesn’t seem to be into telecommunication and internet that much.
March 25th, 2011 on 6:20 am
Sorry, Typo again, I meant “…Within the last monthS at least seven movie projects approached him …
March 25th, 2011 on 2:59 pm
“But look at the things from his point of view. Within the last month at least seven movie projects approached him, and of course all of these projects have fans who want him to play that role.”
Not really.
1. TMI [Fantasy]
2. The Hunger Games [Fantasy]
Other than Alex saying he met with Lionsgate, there isn’t much to suggest he’s a strong contender for a role in that film, and the fans of the book seem to hate him for the part.
3. The Seventh Son (Wardstone Chronicles / The Spooks (last) Apprentice) [Fantasy]
This seems irrelevant anyway since we know he’s not going to be involved with the project but there’s no evidence of any fan movement wanting him cast.
4. The Paperboy [Thriller]
Again, no evidence of any fan movement wanting him cast or any real evidence this movie is ever going to get made at all. Also, another example of Vulture reporting that Alex Pettyfer is wanted by a movie project. They sure seem obsessed with Alex.
http://nymag.com/daily/entertainment/2011/02/preciouis_director_lee_daniels.html
“We hear that Daniels was in town last week reading young actors for parts, and now hear that he’s made offers to Bradley Cooper, Alex Pettyfer (who should open at No. 1 this weekend in DreamWorks’s I Am Number Four)”
Sorry, guys. Try number three. Wonder where Vulture got this particular piece of spin.
5.The Bourne Legacy [Thriller]
Too early to say much. This one will go to every young actor in Hollywood.
6. Preacher [Comic Adaption]
What little I can find on the topic of this adaptation (being directed by DJ Caruso, who announced that he would be interested in casting Alex in it back before I Am No 4 came out, when he had a vested interest in pretending he wanted to work with Alex again) finds the Preacher fandom vomiting at the concept of AP’s casting.
7. Shunt – The Story of James Hunt [Biopic]
This is a pretend movie that will never be made. Again, announced before Dreamworks released I Am No. 4 and had a vested interest in making AP look like a star for whom they were developing vehicles. Movie isn’t going to happen.
“And it is Alex Pettyfer’s problem to find the right one out of these four plus unknown offers.”
There is a great deal of difference between taking a meeting, reading for a role, and an actual offer. The only one of any of these films we actually know he had an offer for is TMI. In your world, no actor would ever be cast in anything because every time they got an offer they’d be sitting around wondering if maybe they should pass it up in case something else in development that maybe might get offered to them might actually started to happen in the future. You deal with the offers you have, not offers that might happen.
“And apart from being unable to show passion before even the decision is done, many of you discussed about an actor has to twitter to the fans.”
I don’t think anyone’s demanding he get a twitter. But a little less naked self-interest and attitude of bored ignorance would be nice. After all, when asked about whether he was going to be in the Hunger Games (which he pretended to read but obviously hasn’t), he said:
http://www.nextmovie.com/coming-soon/alex-pettyfer-cant-remember-hunger-games/
“”I’ve read the books,” he claims. “I just didn’t know if it was a big thing. Is it bigger than ‘Mortal Instruments?’”
Yeah, that’s really the attitude we want from our Jace.
April 4th, 2011 on 6:08 pm
@Ruby
I agree with you that TMI is the only project that had a fan movement for Alex Pettyfer playing Jace.
But, a) I’m not sure that Alex Pettyfer realizes that since he has his own “virtual Firewall” by ignoring everything that is written in the Internet about him.
b) there are as well isolated fans of that books that would like Alex Pettyfer to play that roles as fans of Alex Pettyfer who’d like him to play in that projects.
And you might be wrong about the James Hunt Story. I found an article in a real newspaper (not tabloid) from the not English-speaking part of the world, dated March 25th that said that the James Hunt Story movie according to Dreamworks is due to be released in 2013.
March 25th, 2011 on 8:47 am
At least someone finally pointed this out. I was trying to be supportive since almost every person seemed to like him, while I was in the minority. If he was appreciative of the role he would of taken it with whatever amount of money. Which sucks for him, seeing this franchise would of gotten him a million times more famous. BUT he does not deserve it. I LOVE Max Irons, and if we can do anything to push this idea, and make it happen–Please let us know!
March 25th, 2011 on 9:15 am
Love the idea of father and son playing father and son. Great post. Max has my support!
March 25th, 2011 on 6:24 pm
I understand your POV of Alex Pettyfer but with all due respect, you don’t know the guy. Fame can twist a perfectly good person into something ugly. For all we know, none of what we know could be legit. Any sane human would break under the pressure he is being put under. As much as it sounds like he is selfish and unsatisfied, we have no right to assume anything and neither do the reprters who write about him.
March 25th, 2011 on 8:37 pm
It’s all legit. The stuff written about his douchery is all legit.
March 25th, 2011 on 9:08 pm
“As much as it sounds like he is selfish and unsatisfied, we have no right to assume anything and neither do the reprters who write about him.”
How dumb are you people? How do you not understand that reporters have sources, that they are not actually allowed to sit around making things up on a whim, or claim that people said things during interviews that they didn’t? I can’t even imagine what it must be like to be you, staggering around in a fog of confusion all day, having literally no idea what’s going on in the world because apparently everything is one grand illusion.
March 25th, 2011 on 8:33 pm
I just read something about his acting up at a photo shoot yesterday.
I never know what to think. It seems like the Media will pick someone and then decide if they like them or not and then play it whichever way plays better (usually negative) however there has been a lot of reports of this kind of behavior.
March 26th, 2011 on 12:28 am
Honestly, I normally don’t believe whatever “rumours” are being published about celebrities but these reports have been circulating for a long time and I believe where there’s smoke, there’s fire.
March 26th, 2011 on 6:09 pm
Honestly, I’d be happy if either Max or Alex got the role, or even some other unknown that the producers thought would be a great fit with Lily and the franchise. I just don’t agree with saying one actor deserves a role more than another without actually seeing he/she act out a part. I only see the actor in each particular role that they play, and whether they brought everything they could to the table in portraying their character – what they do off screen is their business. It’s unfair to cast judgment on whether an actor deserves a role or not based on media commentary. I don’t know Max or Alex personally, and I probably never will, but will I say one’s perfect while the other is an ass based on any celebrity news tabloid (regardless of how “reputable” they are)??? No, no, and oh, no. We should be fair to all actors being considered, and not write anyone off until we’ve actually seen them attempt the role of Jace Wayland.
March 26th, 2011 on 6:45 pm
The Hollywood Reporter is a newspaper not a tabloid. They are required to have sources otherwise they can be sued. And, I know this is true because Cassandra Clare used to work there and she said that on the MI message boards.
I don’t think Alex is a good actor. I’ve seen his last two movies and that’s where my opinion is coming from. Acting is a job so your past work is your resume. In my opinion, Alex wasn’t that impressive. Regardless of his chemistry with Lily, he’s not polished.
My other beef with him is everything else I named in the article which is based on fact. If it weren’t, Alex would’ve sued for millions or the studio would’ve come forward and denied the allegations. None of which happened.
As far as the Max thing – I like him. It’s meant to be fun article like me playing casting director. I’m not trying to sway anyone, I’m just stating my opinion.
March 26th, 2011 on 7:44 pm
Newspapers don’t always print the absolute truth. There are always ways to stretch and exaggerate things within the law – loopholes and carefully placed words, and believe me every tabloid OR newspaper knows how to use them. The Hollywood Reporter can report what they interviewed a producer or film crew member about, but does that make what that film crew member said 100% true? Surely, not.
Also, Cassie Clare, she’s an excellent author and really cool person. I really love her books. But was she responsible/did she have control over every article written at the Hollywood Examiner? Just because one employee does honest and reputable writing/work, doesn’t mean everyone else there does the same.
So you’re saying Alex isn’t a good actor based off of his last two movies? Have you ever seen Tormented? You say “acting is a job” and “past jobs are your resume?” Tell me, does an employer only look at 1 or 2 past jobs when they study your resume? No, they look at your entire resume and work history. He did a great job in that role. I also watched Beastly and I am Number Four, of course not all of his moments were Oscar worthy moments, or even “good” acting in both movies, but there were some moments where I saw glimpses of untapped potential in him. He’s just a bit green behind his ears, and rough around the edges. If given the chance, he could grow into an excellent actor. His resume can become stronger along with his acting, if people stop writing him off because of opinions reported that may or may may not be true. Natalie Portman is a very good example. Her acting was awful in Star Wars, but over the years she’s gotten several roles, and has become a very polished young actress who has one an Academy award. If someone would have told me the girl queen from Star Wars was going to win an Oscar one day when those movies came out, it would have been difficult for me to imagine.
I’m not arguing whether the things said about Alex are true or not because there’s no sure way of proving it. Though saying an article in any newspaper is based on “fact” because a particular person didn’t sue over it is kind of a thin explanation. There are so many factors out there. 1) Maybe he doesn’t read newspapers written about himself? 2) Maybe he’s planning to sue, but hasn’t taken action yet? 3) Maybe he rather focus on going forward with his career instead of getting tied up in a flame war with the media? 4) Maybe he’s just a good little Christian boy who doesn’t believe in suing? (Though this reason is very far fetched.) My point is, there’s just no way to really know the truth, and if you say the article is fact, you’re going to need more proof than “so and so used to work there” and “so and so hasn’t sued.”
As for your last statement, you say you’re just stating your opinion on Max, which is good because I like opinions – they make me think and consider different perspectives. Though, I want to point out that I never accused you of attempting to sway anyone in Max’s corner. I’m just saying it’s not fair to say someone is deserving of a role or not unless you’ve actually seen that person attempt it. You shouldn’t judge them on their ability to take on a role based off how they are off the screen.
So what if Alex asked for 10 million dollars to do MI, and people are claiming that’s making him a greedy ass? It’s called negotiating. Everyone does it. I’m sure there’s been a job or book deal or something that all of us have wanted where we wanted to ask for what we believed we were worth? There’s nothing wrong with that at all. Thus, I don’t think the media or anyone should penalize him for that. People should always have every right to negotiate the terms of a potential job they might take on – and I don’t think they should be called greedy, uncaring, or an ass because of it.
Max, Alex, or anyone else. I’ll give him a chance regardless of what the media says.
March 26th, 2011 on 7:49 pm
oops… one = won. Sometimes my brain goes on the fizzle when I go into a writing frenzy.
March 26th, 2011 on 7:56 pm
It would probably be best to say we agree to disagree which is fine.
March 26th, 2011 on 11:16 pm
As an impartial observer (I don’t know either of these actors) I have to say that your logic is fallacious. I believe it suffers from the fallacy of “denying the antecedent”.
The rule of which is thus: “the consequent in an indicative conditional is claimed to be false because the antecedent is false; i.e. if A, then B; not A, therefore not B”
We can apply it to what you’ve said above, like this:
A = Untrue
B = Would’ve sued
It applies like this: if it’s untrue they would’ve sued they didn’t sue so it is not untrue” i.e. it’s true
July 15th, 2011 on 12:55 pm
Penny, I agree with you in every way. I don’t know anything else to say. THis is Elisa’s sister
March 26th, 2011 on 11:22 pm
Sorry a small correction, it should’ve read: “If it’s untrue then they would’ve sued it’s not untrue so they didn’t sue”
March 27th, 2011 on 3:25 pm
You couldn’t have summed up my point any better. That’s exactly what I was trying to say, but you put it in simpler terms and easier to understand terms. Basically, you can’t say something is true because he or she didn’t sue over it. Thank you, Sam.
July 15th, 2011 on 12:58 pm
personally, I found your terms a lot easier to understand. Sam sounds like a nerd.
March 28th, 2011 on 7:45 pm
I really don’t see Alex as the perfect Jace, he looks too manly for the role IMO. About his acting, I think he could do it, also the stunts. I think the ideal situation is that he attends the casting and wins the role, I mean that I wouldn’t like him to be chosen just because of the fans pressure if there is a better actor for the part out there.
Also if his demands about the payment are true, it could make a difference, because if the movie is not as successful then the relation cost/benefit might reflect on the cancelation of the saga.
I, for example, think that Jeremy Sumpter would make a good Jace, he seems angelic in that way. Maybe having seen him as Peter Pan takes me to Jace, where both are boys, both can be childish, and yet are fierce combatants that develop romantic interest despite themselves :-p Actually… I think I’m going to check if he’s aware of the movie being filmed and interested in the part X-D
March 28th, 2011 on 10:25 pm
THANK. YOU. Someone needed to say it. Alex Pettyfer is a DIVA. Divo? Whatever the proper word is. AND he can’t act. I have had issues with him for quite some time, ever since his stale and crusty performance in the STORMBREAKER movie. He is a well-paid actor. Looks are not everything. They shouldn’t be. He just shouldn’t cut it because of his horrid behaviour.
March 29th, 2011 on 12:50 pm
This kid is 20 years old. Most guys are idiots at this age, but hopefully grow out of it. I feel for this guy, and all these young celebs, because every mistake, every problem is so public. What is more, people think they can judge you and know you based on what a bunch of strangers say.
That being said, I hope he does get the part. I’m not concerned with the specifics of how much they intend to pay him or the other actors. This series has done so well, in terms of book sales, that it’s safe to say it’s going to do exceptionally well in the box office. This is not a low budget film like Twilight, for example. If his managers/people are asking for a lot of money, then they know what they’re doing.
March 30th, 2011 on 12:05 pm
While I do think you make excellent points that I mostly agree with I do just wanna make a few observations…
First off, one of the main reasons you’ve listed to say that pettyfer does not deserve the role is his attitude, but we must remember Jace has one hell of an attitude! Think about it, he wouldn’t give a damn if he showed up late for a premier or something. He swagger in there, with that too cool for school look on his face and sarcastically own the show. Also, he probably would throw a fit about a small salary, but not because he actually cared, just because it would cause trouble for everyone else.
Last, but not least, I have read reviews for both IANF and Beastly and I have seen (and read) IANF. I will say that yes, the reviews about IANF are true, the movie was pretty awful (better than percy jackson though in my opinion) however the book was pretty awful too compared to the TMI series. I felt that pettyfer showed considerable emotional talent and I think that if he has an actual GOOD book/movie adaption script to work with he could really shine.
Just my opinion, but I do think that it would have been wiser if he had jumped on the role when it was offered to him back in January…the waiting game is whats killing him.
April 1st, 2011 on 7:37 pm
I can’t believe you’re actually saying this! so what if his snobby persona resembles jace? do we really want a brat on the sets? no matter how much he is like jace, I don’t think anyone appreciated that kind of attitude in real life.
April 8th, 2011 on 10:25 am
@zara I can’t believe you are actually saying this !
How often and for how long did you meet Alex Pettyfer to know that he’s a brat and what kind of attitude he has in real life ?
Or did you ever talk to his co-actors ? Why don’t you ask Teresa Palmer or Callan McAuliffe, for example ?
And why, do you think, would DJ Caruso like to do more movies with him if he’s such an a****le ?
July 15th, 2011 on 1:01 pm
I agree. Jace can’t be some placid, easy going loser. The actor needs to be Jace in order to pull off Jace.
March 31st, 2011 on 12:01 am
oh, sad! even after reading all this, i still am team alex for jace. however you do make excellent points. and i do agree with you. if he has a bad attitude, he shouldn’t be given the role. its like with jennifer lawrence landing katniss everdeen. she’s not at ALL who i wanted to play katniss, but she was so gracious about being given the role that i’m glad she got it. you know she’ll try her best to please the fans. that’s what we need out of our jace. but i just can’t see him [alex] in that light. i guess you could say i’m blinded to his faults. perhaps his bad attitude could fuel his inspiration for jace (if he got the role.) because lets face it, jace pretty much has a bad attitude also (read: i don’t mind it). while i thought i am number four wasn’t too shabby, i also didn’t have to work with him on set so i have no idea what he’s like to be around…
that being said, i also think max irons would also do a fantastic job. and he sounds very deserving. annnnd he’s not too popular yet which is always a plus. while i didn’t see red riding hood, i’d still trust him with the role because i’ve heard nothing but good about his acting abilities.
March 31st, 2011 on 11:52 am
What Buffy said.
Great topic!
March 31st, 2011 on 11:32 pm
So although alex pettyfer may not be the most humble of people nor the most personable, all the bad characteristics you named sound to me a lot like Jace. In the beginning of the series and through out, Jace is an ass and pettyfer has that down already. And like a lot of people have already said, when given the right role pettyfer does have acting chops and I really think if given the chance to play Jace, he would do the best job…
April 1st, 2011 on 8:18 am
I think even though a lot of people see these characteristics as Jace. This is the reason we call this ACTING! Someone could easily take the role interpretting Jace, but be easy going on set. Lily, and the rest of the people involved with the movie do not deserve to deal with this. I’m not saying these rumors are true, or attacking anyone. I just think we should look further for someone who WANTS to be apart of the movie as someone like Lily does. I’ve seen his interviews, and he sees it as only another role. Why can’t we have someone as Jace who sees beyond that?
April 1st, 2011 on 8:26 pm
I’m sorry but how do you know all of this? Have you lived with Alex? Worked with him? Talked to him? If not, then i suggest you tink before saying this. I mean, the media emphasizes almost eveything about celebrities and most tabloids aren’t even true. They would most likley be false. If your ‘proof’ is other articles about his ‘attitude problems’ then I suggest maybe deleting this. No one but Alex Pettyfer knows who he is and I thnk it’s very ignorant for everyone that’s saying this. He kows who he is, and if he DOES have an ‘attitude problem,’ he would know to change his behaviour. No one with a career like his would want it to crash in a second. I’m sure he would’ve done something by now to change. I know everyone is entitled to their own opinion but I everyone must think before they speak.
April 1st, 2011 on 9:12 pm
Sorry for the grammar mistake
I meant “No one but Alex Pettyfer knows who he is and I think it’s very ignorant for everyone that’s saying that he has an attitude problem.”
April 3rd, 2011 on 12:06 pm
This is from: about.com:
After finishing up interviews with the cast of Priest at WonderCon, I chatted (informally, not an interview) with Screen Gems President Clint Culpepper about the film’s conversion to 3D and about another one of the studio’s upcoming huge projects: The Mortal Instruments. Culpepper said Priest’s conversion to the format will have all the naysayers changing their minds, and even upped the budget to ensure the 3D version would look stunning and win over audiences. And, although I’m not a fan of 3D (the glasses are distracting and most 3D films are too dark), the extra time and money invested in Priest looks like it’s paid off. Footage screened at WonderCon looked incredible, and it’s impossible to tell the film wasn’t shot in the format in the first place.
Culpepper also confirmed he’s still very interested in getting Alex Pettyfer signed up to play Jace in The Mortal Instruments. Culpepper admires Pettyfer and believes he has what it takes to take on one of the lead roles in the film. The two have been exchanging texts, which Culpepper showed to me, about The Mortal Instruments, and the door appears to be wide open if Pettyfer wants to step up and take on the part. And although Pettyfer’s had a fair share of bad press recently, Culpepper says the 20 year old actor isn’t cocky at all.
As for the timing of The Mortal Instruments, Lily Collins (‘Clary’) will be working on Snow White prior to filming The Mortal Instruments which does allow the studio and director Scott Stewart more time to either get Pettyfer signed on or find another actor to fill the pivotal role.
Also of Interest:
April 4th, 2011 on 7:02 pm
Konstantina, you sort of scooped me since I also read that article and wanted to quote from it, too. So, thank you for posting it.
Therefore I can limit myself to the conclusions to draw from it:
I mentioned about almost two weeks ago, that IF the 10 Million Dollar demand story is true, it could only have leaked out from the negotiations from Mr. Culpepper’s side.
Although the press in general is not too reliable, interviews are not that often forged. Therefore I’d like to assume the interview with Mr. Culpepper might be authentic.
“And although Pettyfer’s had a fair share of bad press recently, Culpepper says the 20 year old actor isn’t cocky at all.”
That is not exactly a statement of somebody who is furious for being asked for 10 Million Dollars.
That would indicate that, like most of the stories about Alex Pettyfer in the recent months, this story was made up by the press too.
And slowly I’m becoming both tired and annoyed about all the bad press about Alex Pettyfer, since as time goes by, almost all stories turn out to be unfounded lies by “unnamed sources” and “when there is smoke. there is fire” stories. However in this case the smoke seems to be artificial.
All that is left is that he wasn’t happy about the payment on “Ia#4” after learning that one of his co-actors got a higher royalty and that he was late on two occasions.
And about the “critical reviews” about his work, I don’t need reviewers to tell me who is a good or bad actor. I’ve my eyes, my ears, my brain and my experience, and following that Alex Pettyfer is neither a bad nor a wooden actor.
I totally understand that not all people might like Alex Pettyfer’s play, and some people may not like his look or his face. That is a matter of personal taste.
April 3rd, 2011 on 4:38 pm
So, what does Alex bashers have to say about that new article?
If Alex was so much of a jerk as the reports were suggesting wouldn’t Culpepper want to run a mile instead of being STILL interested in him for the role of Jace and still keeping in contact with him?
What I’m trying to say here is that don’t believe EVERYTHING you read because truth is always mix with fiction. Take whatever you read about Alex with a grain of salt.
Besides, Culpepper doesn’t think Alex is cocky AT ALL. So take that Alex haters!
April 11th, 2011 on 7:13 pm
Of course Culpepper would say that! Hes so desperate for jace because he was/is the fan favourite. They don’t want the samw backlash that the hunger games casting recieved.
Culpepper, to me, seems to be sucking up to alx just because he seems to be the major choice from obstinate biased shallow kids who are saying alex LOOKs like their perfect jace.
I hate to break it to you, but have you seen A RECENT picture of him? I admit he used to LOOK very jace-like with his blonde hair and abs. Now he has pathetic stubble growing-ok he can shave. BUT HIS HAIR!! PLEASE LOOK AT IT. its black-greasy. he looks sooo bad at the moment.
And he was OFFERED the movie. Why does every other actor n Hollywood realised what an amazing opp to play jace would be!?
Why do we have to BEG alex to play jace like hes some kind of God!? In HOt Topic signing-many fans told him they love him as jace. Why does Clare say to us that we have to tweet to get alex as jace. Implying that Screen Gems will choose who the fans like more. Which is not based on acting ability or screen tests!
April 3rd, 2011 on 8:05 pm
Anon ^^ I acually love you right now!! you said it, I couldn’t agree more!
April 4th, 2011 on 8:42 pm
Ruby:
“’But look at the things from his point of view. Within the last month at least seven movie projects approached him, and of course all of these projects have fans who want him to play that role.’
Not really.
1. TMI [Fantasy]
2. The Hunger Games [Fantasy]
Other than Alex saying he met with Lionsgate, there isn’t much to suggest he’s a strong contender for a role in that film, and the fans of the book seem to hate him for the part.”
In the case of The Mortal Instruments, it is clear, especially given the comments recently by Mr. Culpepper, that the role is his for the asking. In the case of The Hunger Games there’s not much indication that he was a strong contender, and also not much indication that he was interested. The only thing Alex has said about that movie is that he took a meeting. To say that fans of the book hate him for the part is misleading. Some did, some didn’t. Fans don’t really cast movies though- if they did, Josh Hutcherson surely would not be playing Peeta.
“3. The Seventh Son (Wardstone Chronicles / The Spooks (last) Apprentice) [Fantasy]
This seems irrelevant anyway since we know he’s not going to be involved with the project but there’s no evidence of any fan movement wanting him cast.”
Why is this irrelevant? He was offered the role and he turned it down. I haven’t seen much evidence of any substantial fandom for this series of books, but there were certainly fans who would have liked him to play this role, despite him being all wrong for it. (But not as wrong as the 24 year old actor they eventually cast as the 12 year old)
“4. The Paperboy [Thriller]
Again, no evidence of any fan movement wanting him cast or any real evidence this movie is ever going to get made at all. Also, another example of Vulture reporting that Alex Pettyfer is wanted by a movie project. They sure seem obsessed with Alex.”
Again, not really a book with a fandom, seeing how it is not a recent book and was written for grownups. A lot of Alex’s fans would like to see him in this role, but I guess that doesn’t count to you. And there’s just as much evidence that The Paperboy will get made as any other project on this list. No movie is a sure thing until it actually goes into production, and even then, not always.
“’We hear that Daniels was in town last week reading young actors for parts, and now hear that he’s made offers to Bradley Cooper, Alex Pettyfer (who should open at No. 1 this weekend in DreamWorks’s I Am Number Four)”
Sorry, guys. Try number three. Wonder where Vulture got this particular piece of spin.’”
I Am Number Four was widely expected to open at number one based on the publicity push it was getting from Disney. That’s why the said “should” instead of “will.” As it is, it opened at #2, not #3. It was only #3 if you count Monday’s receipts as part of the weekend, which we don’t. http://boxofficemojo.com/movies/?id=iamnumberfour.htm
“5.The Bourne Legacy [Thriller]
Too early to say much. This one will go to every young actor in Hollywood.”
According to Deadline Hollywood, Alex was on the short list for this despite the fact that he is ten year younger than anyone else who was considered. Not too surprising that he wasn’t cast.
“6. Preacher [Comic Adaption]
What little I can find on the topic of this adaptation (being directed by DJ Caruso, who announced that he would be interested in casting Alex in it back before I Am No 4 came out, when he had a vested interest in pretending he wanted to work with Alex again) finds the Preacher fandom vomiting at the concept of AP’s casting.”
Actually, Caruso mentioned first mentioned Alex for Preacher when they were promoting I Am Number Four in France, weeks after the movie opened in the USA. It is also very clear from their interviews together that Caruso and Pettyfer have a very friendly, relaxed relationship. Either that or they are two of the best actors alive. As far as the Preacher fandom’s reaction, they are opposed to all of Caruso’s casting idea’s and to Caruso himself, but fandoms don’t cast movies. Just ask Gaspard Ulliel how much he enjoys playing Edward Cullen.
“7. Shunt – The Story of James Hunt [Biopic]
This is a pretend movie that will never be made. Again, announced before Dreamworks released I Am No. 4 and had a vested interest in making AP look like a star for whom they were developing vehicles. Movie isn’t going to happen.”
“And it is Alex Pettyfer’s problem to find the right one out of these four plus unknown offers.”
This is pure cynical conjecture on your part. Alex has been developing this project for years. Dreamworks did not enter into a producing agreement with Alex and option a book for a fake project in order to publicize a movie. There are other, less expensive ways to do that.
“There is a great deal of difference between taking a meeting, reading for a role, and an actual offer. The only one of any of these films we actually know he had an offer for is TMI. In your world, no actor would ever be cast in anything because every time they got an offer they’d be sitting around wondering if maybe they should pass it up in case something else in development that maybe might get offered to them might actually started to happen in the future. You deal with the offers you have, not offers that might happen.”
An in your world every actor is so desperate that they jump at every role that is offered them, despite the fact that they may have other offers on their plate. You seem to think you have some kind of inside information, but you don’t. I know of at least two other projects that he has been offered, maybe he’d rather do one of those. Maybe he is wary of yet another adaptation of a YA novel. I don’t know. Neither do you.
“And apart from being unable to show passion before even the decision is done, many of you discussed about an actor has to twitter to the fans.”
“I don’t think anyone’s demanding he get a twitter. But a little less naked self-interest and attitude of bored ignorance would be nice. After all, when asked about whether he was going to be in the Hunger Games (which he pretended to read but obviously hasn’t), he said:
http://www.nextmovie.com/coming-soon/alex-pettyfer-cant-remember-hunger-games/
“”I’ve read the books,” he claims. “I just didn’t know if it was a big thing. Is it bigger than ‘Mortal Instruments?’”
Yeah, that’s really the attitude we want from our Jace.”
The rest of this is just holier-than-thou bull. You are assuming all kinds of things based on very little. I’m sorry that he doesn’t wet himself any time someone mentions The Mortal Instruments. I’m sorry that as an actor picking a role self-interest must play a part. I don’t even know how to address the “bored ignorance” comment because it is so out of touch with reality. But mostly I’m sorry that so many people in the Mortal Instruments fandom are so judgmental and narrow minded. It’s sad really.
April 5th, 2011 on 6:42 pm
At this point I really don’t know. Although I do favor Max Irons, I believe whoever is doing the casting knows better than myself. Alex is extremely cute as well, and I’m sure he will do awesome as Jace if given the role. The only thing that bothers me is the attitude problem, but I don’t know him personally as others have said–he could be shy. I will just leave it up to Screen Gems to decide! Either way I am a big fan, and will see it with whoever is casted. It sucks we all have to argue over it, but at least we are passionate enough to care right?
April 6th, 2011 on 11:18 pm
Yes i agree pettyfer should not be jace, but with his attitude and the pore acting, i am led to believe that he could pull off sabastion
April 7th, 2011 on 9:50 pm
I still hope Alex Pettyfer agrees to play Jace!
April 10th, 2011 on 7:34 am
So do I, and according to what has been reported lately, the chances are not that bad.
May 2nd, 2011 on 9:56 pm
SO DO I!!!
July 15th, 2011 on 1:09 pm
Same
April 12th, 2011 on 2:31 pm
First of all, thank you very much for your detailed and very well argumented article. Let me say some words. I suppose, that we are well informed, that Alexander is not only an actor, he is also a model. So, what’s the conclusion? The models usually are people with a great body and vision. Moreover, people, who really love their bodies, who really enjoy themselves. Narcissism, isn’t it? So, on one side, we have narcissism, on the other side we have all these fans, who want Alexander to play Jace? And finally, Alexander really looks like Jace. He has no reason to refuse except two things. First, money of course. And second, because of somebody else, who has a big influence on him /hope it’s not some woman, it will be really foolish/. But he, and all his fans must realize, that Mortal Instruments is not equal to Alexander Richard Pettyfer. The movie must start no matter who is going to play Jace. As to Alexander, I have no bad feelings to him. I don’t care why he was late for his own premiere or what he is doing at home – it’s his personal life. If he loves his fans he will be Jace, but if he loves money more even if he accepts he WON’T be Jace. I think he should accept. And if he is not going to do it I think he should explain why. Not through any PR agencies, agents, medias, newspapers…blah, blah, blah. Himself. Because, we deserve to know why?
April 20th, 2011 on 11:47 am
I don’t see why his attitude is such a big deal for his portrayal of Jace. Dude, come on. It’s not like he’s the only jerk actor (IF he even is) in Hollywood. He got into an argument, you say it’s unprofessional. I think not. An argument need not always be oppressive. We don’t know how it went, we don’t know if the way Alex approached the director was RUDE and COCKY, as you guys imply. We don’t know a lot of things.
Tabloids are alive because of fabricated stories. I’m sorry, but it’s the truth. Most paparazzi news are lies or modified truths. They get a living out of it. We’re not a hundred percent sure the stories aren’t true, but we’re not a hundred percent sure they are either. Either way, this isn’t a Mr. Nice Guy competition, this is a movie production. I’m sorry, but in this industry, I doubt being nice is the first thing the take into consideration.
Alex is wanted by most fans because he looks the part, but believe it or not, some want him because they’ve actually seen his movies and scrutinized it and thought, hey! This guy might just be the right Jace. We’re not all the shallow, okaaay. To be honest with you, I wasn’t all to impressed with I Am Number Four and I’m yet to see Beastly. I was however, impressed with his performance in Wild Child: the charming Jace, and Stormbreaker: the shadowhunter. I tried to consider the other options, but they just don’t cut it. Bottomline is, he can act. Alright, guys?
Not passionate. Gosh, how could you guys possibly know? He said he loved the books, he hasn’t accepted the offer, unlike Lily Collins, he didn’t create a Twitter account to update us fans, therefore he is not passionate. How can we know? He is a busy, working person. He doesn’t even have a Twitter account.
I’m sure the director isn’t considering AP simply because the fans want him. If he does, then he is no fourth-rate director.
If I don’t get Alex Pettyfer as Jace, then fine. I’m still seeing the movie. But if you’re asking for a vote, then I vote for him.
April 26th, 2011 on 12:58 am
Your right I never really thought that people could makes stories.
May 2nd, 2011 on 10:00 pm
i agree with EVERYTHING you said. i would love alex to play jace. and also i saw I am number four and beastly and thought that alex was pretty darn good!!! i dont care about reporters and all that crap cuz i cant believe any of it. (to an extent) but still.
April 26th, 2011 on 12:54 am
I loved the series and what I hear about Alex makes me feel quizzy. But then when I saw “I Am Number Four” it made me feel like… like… I was dreaming. I did not like the movie and I was thinking, “If Alex Pettyfer plays the role in this movie Cassandra would get bad book reveiws just because of that movie.”, I mean I don’t want to see her quit making books.
I LOVE her books, it was the best series I think I would ever read in my whole entire life, and I don’t want to see a movie make it a bad reputition on the books. I mean think about these books not even being read the writer not popular anymore. I mean when I saw the book in the library it was old and damaged. As if it were recked because it was a bad book (I though that because most of the books were beaten up because some people in our libary damage them if they are bad).
But no, I was wrong I looked in the book and could not stop reading, I was traped in the writers imagination. I loved the book so much! But then I heard that Cassandra Clare was going to stop writing The Mortal Instruments series at the City of Glass. To my suprise was that the week after her saying people went to full support and posted on her facebook walls “Please don’t stop making your books! We love them!” and after that she came up with new exiting books like…
The Infernal Devices series and also continuing the The Mortal INstrumets series with City of Fallen Angels (In stores on April 4th to 5th), City of Lost Souls (Can buy on Amazon, ONLY AMAZON! What I heard), and City of Heavenly Fire (Also on Amazon, just Amazon)
Though I really hope they DO make a movie and that it WILL have awesome charecters!
April 26th, 2011 on 2:13 pm
Actually Kimberly it has been proven true hes asked for that much,and it has alos been verified that they will continue the movies even if he doesnt want the part..I think asking for 10 million is insane especially when your a barely known actor,unless hes spot on perfection but I doubt it.But then again I wouldnt know.I can guarentee this though,no matter who they choose will not be the 100% perfect or correct Jace to any of us,what might be right to one will be wrong to the next..And yes your right were not the director and we cant change it but he still hasnt even decided what movie he wants to do yet.Im sorry I just dont want to see this badass series ruined like Twilight or other movies that were books first.Im not exactly a twilight fan I read the books and liked them at first then In my opinion I found some very very wrong things with the book..
May 1st, 2011 on 8:06 pm
@Roxy
I read dozens of articles a day about Alex Pettyfer from all over the planet. However from your statement I understand that I must have missed some important information in spite of that.
We should perhaps keep in mind what Mr. Clint Culpepper, the president of Sony Screen Gems, said about Alex Pettyfer: “Culpepper says the 20 year old actor isn’t cocky at all” ! He wouldn’t say that if he had been asked for an exorbitant amount of money.
But if you have a source that knows more than the president of the studio who is shooting “City of Bones”, why don’t you share your source with us ?
April 26th, 2011 on 3:12 pm
Actually, Roxy, no it has not been proven that he asked for $10 million at all. It was reported in one magazine, a magazine that was FORMERLY a respected trade paper, in an article that didn’t list a single source or follow the simple rules of responsible journalism. So, you’re wrong.
April 26th, 2011 on 6:40 pm
Wrong or right…we have the right to know exactly what is going on, because a lot of people already want Alexander to play Jace. I think some of them will watch the movie even only because of Pettyfer’s acting. $10 million is a very VERY huge number but in the face of the love and the respect of a fan…I think it is nothing…well I think Pettyfer will answer that…soon. Therefore we need an explanation, simple and argumented…as it was Stacey’s article. It is true, that there is no treaty, only rumors. But these rumors only tantalize the fans. Until when? I have the feeling that the movie itself could be postpone only because of Pettyfer’s role. Come on, guys, this is ridiculous. I don’t know why he is so busy, but Twitter might be a good decision. And I will give you a simple example. Logan Lerman, who played Percy Jackson has a wonderful formsping wall, where he has THE TIME to answer the questions of his fans – easy and comfortable, isn’t it? So, it is possible. And finally, I think that the time for a decision is coming. And if Alexander Pettyfer choose Jace…the I can wish him good luck and congratulate him for this decision. But if he doesn’t choose Jace I could say good like in his acting career. And when I heard the news for those $10 million I said to myself: Man, perhaps this guy is not like Jace Wayland.
April 26th, 2011 on 10:49 pm
I was actually for him playing Jace until the 10 mill. rumor,and the fact that he went a-wall on his ex.Hey,maybe he was just having some bad days like well all do,but his attitude is another thing that worries me.I never said I hated him or was trying to diss him.But its been almost 5 months since he was offered the part,I know these things take ALOT of time,and hes been offered about 2 othe movies.I just want to see the movie back on the roll.And any of you.The Hollywood reporter IS a newspaper,not some tabloid..Look Im not trying to pick fights,If I find out its wrong Ill be happy to admit it.I also wasnt impressed with his past movies..His so called bad attitude does seem Jace like but We’ll never know until we see it ourselves
April 27th, 2011 on 9:17 am
Sorry but you don’t know what you are talking about. Hollywood Reporter was a newspaper until about a year ago when it changed owners and was “reinvented” as a glossy magazine. Also, as I have pointed out before, the Hollywood Reporter article was pure tabloid, quoting only anonymous “insiders” as sources- there actually was not a single named source in the article. That is not journalism, that’s rumor-mongering.
April 27th, 2011 on 3:40 pm
Here, he’s quoted from a magazine interview he did. http://tinyurl.com/3mcldnc Do you still think all the reports are wrong now? Dude’s got serious attitude issues.
May 1st, 2011 on 9:09 pm
@Stacey O’Neale
The article at E!Online is a very good example that a lot of rubbish is published about Alex Pettyfer. and it is also a good example to see how the press works, because a lot of publications brought the same “facts” and referred to or quoted E!Online. But wrong facts can’t turned right by repeating them in a lot of publications.
Actually Alex Pettyfer didn’t really tell about that tattoo to “VMan”. Did anybody ever thought about why he winked ? It was to indicate to the interviewer that he was making a joke !
But it seems some people even don’t recognize a joke if it is clearly indicated by a wink !
He does have a tattoo on his lower waist in fact. However, it doesn’t say “Thank you”. It is his own name written in Japanese Kanji Signs.
And many fans know about his tattoos and the pictures of the tattoo have been available on the Internet for at least 18 month. So everybody can see that the so called “fact” published in dozens of publications around the world is wrong and the “journalists” do not check anything before they publish it.
The same thing with the c-word. If anybody would have checked a dictionary he/she might have find out that (perhaps not in the US [?] but) in all other countries on the planet the c-word is known gender-unspecific with the meaning of a**hole . And from the context in the “Vman”-Interview you can see that it was not meant gender-specific at all.
And by the way, I liked the interview on “VMan”. Why shouldn’t Alex Pettyfer have his own opinion instead of having an opinion composed by a PR-Agent ?
May 1st, 2011 on 8:33 pm
Even you will have to admit that the stories the Hollywood Reporter brought some month ago about Alex Pettyfer (fore example his engagement to Dianna Agron) turned out to be wrong meanwhile.
So The Hollywood Reporter is definitely no reliable source.
And to quote the Hollywood Reporter article from April 28th: ‘The British actor reveals he has a tattoo above his pelvis that says “thank you” in case he forgets to thank the women he gets intimate with.’
What kind of journalism is this ? There are pictures of the tattoo available on the Internet for one and a half years now, and ten thousands of fans now that the tattoo does not say “Thank you” but is his name in Japanese Kanji Signs.
So how can The Hollywood Reporter (and a lot of other papers) dare to write such a stupid story if so many people know it is not true and everybody can check it on the Internet ?
And when Alex Pettyfer makes a joke in an interview about something which can easily be checked and even indicates by winking that it is a joke, how can people take that seriously. From grown up people I would expect that they have heard about the existence of jokes !?
May 1st, 2011 on 9:16 pm
Yes, this latest bull-flop about Alex having Thank You written on his pelvis is actually quite typical. First the interviewer at V Man didn’t understand it was a joke, then Ted Casablancas, a gossip columnist, reports it (but inserts a whole lot of outrage into his coverage), then Perez Hilton steals it from Casablancas (almost word of word) taking exactly the same things out of context in exactly the same way, and then thousands of content farms, aggregators and pirate bloggers steal it and repeat it verbatim. Then The Hollywood Reporter, without doing any actual checking, reports it as fact. And now it’s out there and when someone points out their error do you suppose they acknowledge it and correct it. Hell to the no. And then, based on this kind of gossip we have people saying that he doesn’t deserve the role. Right. And do not tell me that he isn’t a good enough actor for the role either. I’ve seen all his movies and I know that he’s plenty good enough, and probably better than a film from the director of Legion and Priest deserves. So don’t quote bad reviews at me. I can quote good reviews right back at you. And I can quote some really bad reviews of your precious Max Irons at you as well.
July 15th, 2011 on 1:21 pm
Why does it matter where he sticks a tattoo anyway? It was a joke!
April 27th, 2011 on 5:57 pm
Well, that article takes quotations from the magazine article out of context, but I will make these points: 1) the thing about the “thank you” tattoo is a joke. The tattoo on his lower abdomen actually says Alex in Kanji. 2) The use of “the c word” is not uncommon in the UK and does not refer to women in general. 3) If it’s his language, sorry, it does not bother me. 4) Nothing he says about Hollywood is untrue, he’s just honest enough to say it. His point- that he doesn’t like it there because it is filled with backstabbing lowlifes- and that he would like to be like Johnny Depp (who he in no way insults, I don’t know where that idea comes from) who also spends as little time there as possible, is completely valid. Ted Casablancas, though, is a serious hypocrite for making a big deal about it. So, if being honest means he has an attitude problem, we need more attitude problems.
April 27th, 2011 on 6:25 pm
He has a lot of attitude for an unproven actor. Bottom line: He should keep his opinions to himself. Ever heard the saying, “don’t shit where you eat”? Well, if you want to make movies, then it’s probably not a good idea to talk about how crappy the people are who might be hiring you or that you might be working with. He’s creating a bad image of himself.
July 15th, 2011 on 1:22 pm
I agree
April 27th, 2011 on 9:26 pm
So essentially you believe that he doesn’t “deserve” a role because you are the arbiter of what people can think or say. Is that it? It’s much better to be a lilly livered coward who pretends that everything is all lollipops and jello even when it isn’t. Yeah, that’s very Jace-like. Freedom of speech? To Hell with that!
April 27th, 2011 on 10:22 pm
LOL. Yes, I am the “arbiter” of what people can think or say. I am the master of this blog universe.
May 1st, 2011 on 4:16 pm
so what if its jace like…actors ACT thats what they do, any actor can ACT like jace. HOWEVER when the actor is such a FREAKING OBNOXIOUS JERK that he should be blacklisted from Hollywood, no thank you!! because thats just PLAIN rude, he aint ALL that soo he should NOT act ALL THAT…the article point out everything really
“In addition to poor tickets sales, I wasn’t impressed with his acting talent and I’m not alone. Most of the extremely poor critical reviews of both movies have said that Alex has failed to deliver any emotion in either role. Mortal Instruments fans know that Jace is a complicated character who requires an actor with range. Alex is unproven, if not disappointing” —> like i said he AINT ALL THAT!!!
May 1st, 2011 on 9:36 pm
Well, sorry, but I don’t judge movies or actors by “critical reviews” or ticket sales. I watch the movie and allow myself to have my own opinion. And I wasn’t disappointed by “Ia#4″ and had several screenings of it on the big screen.
And Alex had main characters in seven movies now and the genres (Historic Drama, Action, Love, Horror, Fantasy, SciFi) is at least a range of genres. And even in his first role as “Tom Brown” he shows range because his character swiftly changes and develops.
July 15th, 2011 on 1:23 pm
ain’t? Are you a hillbilly? Nobody but trailer trash say ain’t.
May 6th, 2011 on 10:15 pm
this is perhaps the most ridiculous entry ever written. you must trust every tabloid source, don’t you? i don’t believe for a second that any of these stories are real but perhaps overdramatised. they are definitely picking on alex. if you have ever seen any interviews of this actor, he is very humble, well read, sarcastic and funny as hell. i think it’s pretty rude for you to say that someone is undeserving because you like to read Us Magazine. if they are depicting alex as arrogant, sarcastic and vulnerable, then what the hell, that is jace wayland. alex pettyfer would be perfect for the role. trust me, i’m The King, i know.
May 7th, 2011 on 5:36 pm
I also know, that he will be the best choice, but I’m not sure that Alexander wants it. I don’t beleive in everything, which those tabloid sources say…but I don’t see anything else instead. It’s time for us to see an interview or at least an article in order to have information what’s going on with that role. Because there are other candidates and time is running out. The patience of the fans is too precious for the producers.
May 7th, 2011 on 6:04 pm
I’ve made myself very clear which side I’m on in the Alex debate, but the one thing I think is so funny is when people take this stance that the producers need to be keeping us in the know, that “we deserve to know” and that time is running out. How is time running out? They will make the movies when they are good and ready to make the movies. Sometimes it takes years, decades. We may not be getting any news because there is no news to tell. And the producers don’t owe us anything but good movies, and if we get that we should count ourselves as damn lucky.
May 17th, 2011 on 9:06 pm
i so agree and its true
May 7th, 2011 on 8:54 pm
Isn’t it strange, dear Chris, that we think in the same way with you. You want the movie done. You want the best choice – Alexander. You want the best “Mortal Instruments” movie. You want the others to agree with you. Me too. So, what’s the only problem we’ve got? The lack of information and the poor PR. The could at least make a news portal for the Mortal Instruments movie. As to the producers – ok, no need to inform us. But then the yellow press will continue to spread its rumors…and if there is no official source to reject or confirm a rumor…then I’m afraid, that we haven’t the right to judge the fans about reading those papers. Besides, this case is unusual. We have a great amount of fans, who really want Alexander to perform Jace. And he will make a great mistake if he doesn’t accept.
May 17th, 2011 on 9:03 pm
honestly i don’t agree with this article for one have of the shit that comes out of the tabloids is BULLSHIT just like the time when they said in the papers like star and people and so on that tyra banks was like 250 or so pounds and showed a picture of her that they made up themselves and called her a fatass model and she proved on her show wearing the same bathing suit and everything and looked at the camera and pretty much told off the papers and told them to kiss her fat ass ……. so guess what i don’t believe have the stuff that comes out of the press cause all they are doing is selling papers and making billions of dollars and don’t care who they hurt and i also liked beatly and number four they where great movies and alex did a great job …. or you know what would be really great if there was someone that followed people that are paparazzis and who worked for the press that would show pics of them and stupid shit they do or how greedy they are honestly i love the books they where the best and i also loved twilight so don’t diss about that since alot of ppl did i love the books and loved the movies just as i am looking forward to the mortal intruments movies but i do hope alex is picked he has the looks the acting abilities and if he doen’t get it he doesn’t but talking shit about him isn’t right and you wouldn’t want someone to make shit up about you
and for stacy how do we know anything you say is true for one you work for the same ppl that lie about alot of ppl just to sell papers and magazines which is pretty like high school you lie make up gossip just to make you feel good and put someone else down ya maybe you should grow up …but i stand by my opinion and if you don’t like i don’t care
May 17th, 2011 on 9:28 pm
This is so funny that I had to reply. I don’t “work” for anyone. I’m an independant writer and no one paid me to write this article. This is my personal blog with my opinions.
PS: He’s no longer in the running so you wasted a whole lot of time writing this comment.
May 17th, 2011 on 10:43 pm
I don’t think that someone pointing out bullshit is ever a waste of time, whether he is in the running to play Jace or not. For the record, I’m sorry for all of the TMI fans who are disappointed that Alex won’t be Jace, but I’m happy that Alex has chosen do a movie with one of the best living film directors instead of yet another YA adaption directed by a man who has yet to make a decent movie.
As for the three that seem to be up for the part, I find them all wanting, but I hope Ed Speleers gets it, even if it turns out to be the second time he’s played in one of Alex’s cast offs.
May 17th, 2011 on 9:53 pm
Actually Tyra did GAIN alot of weight and she even said so herself on her show at the time,because alot of bs was coming out of it she didnt gain 250 but she got up to 200 and that was her own words..ANd alot of people diss twilight because Edward is a Pediphile who is 109 yrs old dating a 17 yr old.Bella is a clingy teenage girl who mops around oh no my life sucks blah blah..Dont get me wrong I read all 4 books and even a part of the 5th one on Myers website but there were just a few things wrong with them like the pediphile thing..TMI totally blows Twilight out of the water..You dont see Clary acting like a zombie if Jace turns her down.she gets hurt yeah but Bella overreacts and takes it to hard,sure weve all had our hearts ripped out of our a$$e$ but that is not a good role model for the teens we have today.Specially this generation..Yes this generation Need I say more.Dont attack people I know not all of our teens these days are drugged out sluts but jeez what happened to there morals?
May 20th, 2011 on 3:58 pm
I’m very happy that there are people here, who care about the values. The values are fundamental in the society and for the freedom. There is no free society without values. The “Pettyfer case” is also a question of values. If one is to understand the full logic of an actor like Alexander he must study all his aspects, not just the rumors. And Stacey did it in this article. I think Edward Speelers will be the best choice in this case. He has the quolities, he has the ambition, he has fans, and the most important – he WANTS it. If there is a motivation we have a good cast. If Alexander has no motivation to do it, he can continue to read the books. Perhaps one day he will realize what he is missing.
May 29th, 2011 on 8:55 pm
Hmm just interested.. has anyone stopped thinking that Alex wouldn’t get the part, and that there are tons of other rumors going on about who’s gonna get it.
On IMD it says the Alex Pettyfer is rumored.
so does it with Nico Tortorella who recently had a smaller breakout in the new Scream 4 movie.
Then I read a few articles, and apparently this one: http://tmisource.com/2011/05/17/report-three-actors-up-for-the-role-of-jace-in-mortal-instruments/
Says three guys did a test screening with Collins.
- Jamie Campbell Bower
- Ed Speelers
- Leebo Freeman
Bower must be a busy man. I mean, he’s finishing up the Twilight Saga – where he plays Caius in the last two parts, which is two movies already. And then he has the part of Grindelwald in the last Harry Potter movie, and a new show called Camelot recently started airing on the Starz channel – so sure, he must be busy. Though all of his movies are post-production, which is basically the editing phase and getting ready for publicity.
Ed Speelers is probably the guy with not that much experience, and especially not compared to Bower. He had his breakout with Eragon, but it didn’t make enough money for a second one (there might be other reasons due to that), and his latest movies haven’t been aired internationally, so maybe a breakout as Jace Wayland would be good for his career, but according to me he’s just a bit too cute to play the edgy Jace, but if he’s a good enough actor then he can switch into a Jace-mood, and he seems to have a schedule that fits. And he seems to have let his hair grow out, if you check recent pictures from him.
Leebo Freeman. Who is this again, was my first reaction? He’s the guy with the least experience. He’s been in one movie: The Aspect from 2008 – which is not a big movie, nor did he have a big role. Though he is a model, and seems to be pretty good at it. Lately many models are pursuing acting career. Rosie Huntington-Whiteley who is a Victoria Secret Model is the new female-lead-character in Transformers 3. Gemma Ward, the Australian supermodel just had a smaller breakout in the new movie: Pirates of the Caribbean 4. But this Leebo Freemen is very hot, and honestly he is hot – my inner teenager is coming out, cause he looks like Jace, maybe a bit more as an emo-version, but he looks very edgy.
Though none of these guys are actually rumored on IMD, which one of the sources I find most reliable.
But until now Alex Pettyfer used to be my favorite. NOW?
I have no clue, but Leebo Freeman just made the top!
June 1st, 2011 on 7:39 am
I had no idea! Man I’m so glad I read this! I am sooo please he is not Jace!
I mean I love the books too, they are so great and I for one will be gutted if the movie turn horribily wrong because of him.
Book films like the Godlen Compass (REAL NAME IS NORTHERN LIGHT FOR CRIPES SAKES!) are disastrous and we cannot have Alex ruin these books
I salute you Stacey!!!
June 1st, 2011 on 7:04 pm
Cassandra Clare has just confirmed earlier today that JAMIE CAMPBELL BOWER is playing the role of Jace in TMI movies,It was posted by her herself on her Google Group The_Mortal_Instruments =]
June 2nd, 2011 on 5:13 pm
Eeeexcellent, now let’s see if 10 000 000 are enough…
June 4th, 2011 on 4:49 am
I have so many thing to say, but i’m only going to say this :
“Some have said that the press is picking on him, but too many people have come out with detailed accounts of this behavior. At some point, you have to use common sense. If it walks like a spoiled brat and acts like a spoiled brat then he’s probably a spoiled brat.”
We had NO proof, not even a little one that he really acts like a ‘spoiled brat’. The press is harsh on him, for whatever reason and they sure like it. But that’s just the way it works .. Maybe 10% of what we’re reading is close to the truth ? The facts are his castmates seems to like him, director too and producer wants to work with him again. It makes no sense ! One thing is sure he stands up for himself and don’t fell into the la-la-land crap. I personally only have respect for him.
“Alex has shown no passion for the role when he should be grateful. Jace Wayland is an incredible character and every actor in town seems to know that except for Pettyfer. ”
I don’t understands you guys .. alright we all wanted Alex, but what about what he wants ??? Not everybody wants to do YA movie for the rest of their lives, no matter how much they pays. Have you ever read any of his interview ? He wants to do *real* movies, stuff he likes. Right now he’s famous enough to have amazing offer ( ex: that stripper movie) . You’re right he had no passion for the role (why should he ??), but he was kind enough to be true to himself and turn it down. Don’t hold the grudge, thank him!
Everybody needs to get over this , whether you wanted him or not.
July 11th, 2011 on 1:44 pm
Yeah,I sort of agree. As Stephanie said earlier, the tabloids should really give him a break. Sure he could use some more emotion in his flicks, but Tormented and Alex Rider were really good! I Am Number Four he left some to be desired (i find he was too rebellious for the character), but you still have to give him credit. Those are hard roles to play! I’m not saying Jace isn’t (because he definitely is) but those were pretty hard and i’m sure that he could still pull it off.
I think you’re being really hard on Alex. About the money thing, it’s not like you’ve heard his side of the story! But he’s like 20-something now! who says he turned down City of Bones just cuz of money. Maybe he doesn’t WANT to play Jace and if they’re gonna practically force him, then he needs more money for it. You’d need to actually hear his reasons before saying he doesn’t *deserve* it!
And whoever ends up playing Jace is probably going to be good, so don’t accuse Alex Pettyfer of being a bad actor when the movie hasn’t even come out yet.
July 13th, 2011 on 2:20 pm
According to Cassie, the only reason that Alex isn’t playing Jace is because he didn’t want to play Jace. That’s his choice. It doesn’t make him a bad person. I have no time at all for people who were all for Alex as Jace and now hate him because he didn’t make their special dream come true.
August 12th, 2011 on 3:55 pm
Alex has a lot of range. His performance in Tormented was very believable and very different from the rest of his roles. It showed a glimpse into confident on the outside yet torn on the inside (towards the end) character. I don’t think he would be messing up the movie and I think that if he took it, it would bring him a LOT of success. I just can’t see this movie failing at the box office. I think it has more potential than the Hunger Games.
Unfortunately I believe Jamie Campbell Bower got the role. Lets see what he does with it.
January 9th, 2012 on 10:51 pm
ok I am still think he would be perfect although i do agree about his needing an attitude check. I just do not see jamie c as jace AT ALL.
January 17th, 2012 on 1:12 am
Yes, still. Because even if he has attitude problems offset, it doesn’t show onset. He’s still a good actor and gorgeous for the role of Jace!
Anyone would be looking for the money. No blame.
July 1st, 2012 on 1:07 am
I’m still trying to understand what his “alleged” attitude has to do with his acting ability… I can name you any number of actors who are “douches” that make really damn good movies. Bottom line: you don’t cast someone in a movie because they’re a “nice dude”. You cast them because they can act. Alex Pettyfer is a DAMN GOOD ACTOR. He would have made a wonderful Jace Wayland. Unfortunately the studio either didn’t want to wait for him or took too damn long to get their shit together because now Alex has completely separated himself from any young adult novel characters. He’s officially in the big leagues with big name actors now. So once upon a time, TMI would have been lucky to have signed this man on before he hit the big time. Now it’s too late. And good riddance. I still think this story is built better for television and if they go forward with the film it will flop. But hey… That’s just my opinion.
January 12th, 2013 on 10:21 am
First, I’ve to say that I’m Spanish, so I don’t speak English very well, but I want to express my ideas as a big TMI fan.
I’m sure that Alex Pettyfer is so idiot as you say, but he’s Jace’s face. The film is destroyed with an ugly or wrong Jace. He’s the star of the movie and the book, and everybody knows how sexy is him, is the first requirement.
For me, Jamie Campbell Bower isn’t Jace. He’s not sexy or good-looking, his face hasn’t got the necessary items.
May 13th, 2013 on 8:03 pm
Besides being blonde, Alex doesn’t look like the Jace I pictured at all.
The actor they chose, Jamie Campbell, much more resembles what I pictured Jace looking like while reading.
The book describes Jace as LEANLY muscular, not really overly buff, and as having blonde hair that sometimes falls into his eyes (indiciating it IS longer hair) and wide set eyes, and attractive but not in that typical model, pretty boy way. Jamie Campbell, the they chose, fits ALL these physcal attributes. So if we’re speaking just physically, he completely fits.
But, I don’t agree that an actor needs to match what readers pictured physically. It’s how the actor embodies the character’s personality and essence that matters, and I don’t know if Alex could do that. From reading comments on Facebook, it seems like half the people that don’t like the casting choice barely payed attention when reading the books, they just picture their own version of hot blonde guy. If you actually pay attention the details of the book make it clear that Jamie resembles Chase way more than Alex. And based on his past acting I think he’ll embody the character beautifully. Apparently, he made the author cry during his audition he was so good. I trust the author and the casting director.
April 4th, 2011 on 8:20 pm
Well, this discussion obviously went from this page to “Shadowhunters Italia”. However it might be helpful to try to keep the discussion on this page in English, which isn’t my native language either, but it helps to be understood by others, since automatic translations still have a very poor quality.
However, I agree that in my opinion there’s no founded reason to argue that Alex Pettyfer might “not deserve the role of Jace Wayland”. And I’m happy that the “Shadowhunter” fans in Italy seem to share my opinion.