My Beef with MG/YA High Fantasy
by Stacey O'Neale on Mar.09, 2011, under Writing Tips
I’m not a big fan of high fantasy; I never have been. I will admit to liking the old fantasy favorites like J. R. R. Tolkien, C. S. Lewis, Terry Brooks, Phillip Pullman, etc. Those guys are some of the ones who put high fantasy on the map, but where have we gone since then? Imitators at best. I can’t tell you the last time I read a high fantasy that truly blew me away. So what’s the problem with high fantasy? Why isn’t it selling as well as it once did? High fantasy isn’t selling because the stories are all the same. To prove it, I will write one for you right now.
In the beginning of my story, my main (male) character will be threatened by an unknown danger. His parents are dead so he has no knowledge of his family history. He is bored with his current life and ready for an adventure. Suddenly, he is attacked by scary creatures. He’s saved by a mysterious, magical, male, older character who will become his mentor. This mentor will teach him about a prophecy/legend where he alone can save the world. There’s also a beautiful damsel in distress ready to be saved. She will be part of the prize because our main character will fall in love with her usually within one or two conversations. Of course, he must first find a hidden magical object that an evil one-dimensional dictator will also be looking for. Predictably, our main character goes on a journey where he will grow into our hero. During this quest, he will be trained to use magic and to fight with swords. He will join a small group of rebels just before his inevitable confrontation with the bad guy. The story will end in an epic battle where our hero will get hurt, but survive, so that we can have room for books two and three of our trilogy. The end.
So you hate me now, right? You think I just flushed an entire fantasy subgenre into one long cliché? Let’s test my theory. I need only look to the NYT Bestsellers list and see that I am not alone in my opinion. Teens are flocking to urban, dark, and paranormal romance. They have been for some time now. Not to mention that most literary agents that I’ve spoken with won’t consider YA high fantasy. Why? Because most middle grade and especially teen readers aren’t interested in world’s they can’t recognize. Sure, there are always exceptions, but not many. Two highly successful exceptions are J. K. Rowling’s Harry Potter series and Rick Riordan’s Percy Jackson’s series, but I don’t consider them high fantasy. They both exist in world’s that are part of ours, but not seen by everyone. The characters have mostly human lives and experiences except that magical element that makes them special.
Okay, so how do we save high fantasy? Easy, come up with an original idea just like all the greats I listed in the top paragraph. They set the standards high so I want more of what they gave us and I want it on a teen level. Show me that and I will be happy to eat my own words.


March 9th, 2011 on 2:05 pm
No fair! You are ruining my blog about the structure of High Fantasy! *evils*
March 9th, 2011 on 3:05 pm
Aren’t Harry Potter and Percy Jackson considered low fantasy as they take part in the human world with magical elements? High fantasy has to be in a completely made up world. I have Terry Goodkinds books-still on my to read list-but the TV show Legend of the Seeker was really good. I’d have to read the books to give you a full verdict, but if the TV show was anything like the books I’d say that was a win for high fantasy. Owls of Ga’hoole would be high fantasy too, movie rocked, still need to read the book. So many books to read so little time.
March 9th, 2011 on 3:42 pm
Harry Potter and Percy Jackson are considered by most to be high fantasy because the bulk of the story takes place in fictional locations (Hogwarts and Camp Half-Blood).
March 9th, 2011 on 4:25 pm
Think Harry Potter and Percy Jackson are a mix of High Fantasy, Contemporary Fantasy and Bildungsroman. Just a personal opinion.
March 10th, 2011 on 8:22 pm
Yes fancy-pants Oxford scholar, I’m sure your much more detailed description is better. LOL!
March 9th, 2011 on 4:29 pm
Of these, I’ve only ever read Harry Potter. I struggle with high fantasy. Not because the plot line is all the same…er, because I’ve never actually finished a high fantasy book or series. I struggle most with the characters. High fantasy books I’ve read really focused on plot and world building, but I never got a sense of who the characters were.
March 9th, 2011 on 5:58 pm
I hear the Wheel of Time books are fantastic, but I have not gotten to them yet. They are about 1000 pages each and I think they are up to 13 books so far…a little daunting. I own most of them for some reason, but it’s a real commitment to dive into High Fantasy, especially a series with that many books in it.
I’ll write you an original High Fantasy one day
Baby steps, let me try and finish my magical realism/low fantasy books first, then I’ll give it a try.
March 9th, 2011 on 8:57 pm
I can see where HF might be a difficult sell for MG and YA. Gah! I can barely keep all the characters straight in George RR Martin’s Song of Ice and Fire series (but still enjoying it). It’s not something you can fall down with on a Sunday afternoon and finish in one sitting. I actually read very little HF because it’s such a struggle!
March 10th, 2011 on 7:43 am
An adult epic/high fantasy that blows away your theory came to my notice in the last two weeks. Maybe kids will pick it up and read it also.
The Kingkiller Chronicles by Patrick Rothfuss beginning with The Name of the Wind.
It is worthy of my antique oak bookshelf, displayed side by side with my battered copy of LOTR.
The second in the three-book series came out this month, Wise Man’s Fear.
I downloaded the free sample of the first book to my Kindle, read maybe three pages, then bought the Kindle version of the book.
I loved it so much, I bought the actual paper and binding novel to rest on my bookshelf.
March 10th, 2011 on 8:14 pm
It’s totally true that too much high fantasy (whether it’s MG, YA, or Adult) follows the same battered path in their plot. I absolutely can not stand Eragon for this very reason. It just feels bland and tired to me.
I’ve been hopelessly obsessed with high fantasy since I was a little kid though, and so no matter what I’m gonna be faithful to my baby. It’s the very reason why I want to write a YA high fantasy. I don’t want teenagers to end up completely spurning that genre. It has too much to offer. That and then there’ll be no one to read the Adult high fantasy books if they don’t get snagged when they’re kids.
Robin McKinley is my hero for this reason. She is why I love high fantasy. I read The Blue Sword and The Hero and the Crown when I was pretty young, and I fell in love with the genre immediately.
Otherwise, have you read Graceling? It and Fire are both YA high fantasy, and I thought they were pretty good. Had a fairly unique premise too.
March 10th, 2011 on 8:21 pm
I bought Graceling, but alas, have not read it yet. I know I’m a hundred years behind. I will read it at some point though. I’ve heard great things about it.
March 11th, 2011 on 8:31 am
David Gemmell’s books? It’s hard to think of anyone else who has managed to take the bare bones of a stale sub-genre and make them so damn entertaining, but making note of Gemmell is akin to preaching to the converted. Few people I have mentioned his books to ever seem to actually go and pick them up.
It’s slightly worrying that the other examples which immediately came to mind all dated back to the sixties and seventies – the Conan paperbacks I’m discounting as they were spun off of older stories, and the endless additions to other continuities seem to require an existing knowledge of the characters. New (and original) stories which get me excited are rather thin on the ground.
The prevalence of D&D (and, to a similar effect, Warhammer) has saturated fantasy with a whole slew of imitators in prose form, and that can’t be discounted as a reason why the exploration and expansion of high fantasy has stalled in favor of continuing with what works. Or, at least, what sells.
March 11th, 2011 on 9:06 am
I agree with some of what you said. I’ve read so much trash. I love High Fantasy but feel like a lot of people are trying to be Tolkien/Pullman/Lewis, and not pulling it off – I am probably one of them!
– But I have to mention, Tad Williams. An awesome author who I feel deserves more credit than he gets. Memory, Sorrow and Thorn is one of the best stories I’ve ever read.
Also, Rose of the Prophet. Another set of books I recommend. Found the story very entertaining and also gives the reader a lot to think about regarding religion etc.
Never read Wheel of Time. My mother was obsessed with it for years but said by book 8? 10? (Summat like that) the story lost it for her so I never bothered.
April 11th, 2011 on 11:56 am
I do agree that many of today’s high fantasy books follow similar paths. I have not read too much in the way of high fantasy, particularly because they sound the same and thus are boring to me.
However, I did enjoy Jennifer Fallon’s Second Son Trilogy because it was based off of a mathmatical equation and was deep in political intrigue. It shattered-in my opinion-the genre’s take on religion because it dispelled the world’s belief system entirely. However, when I read her Hythrun Chronicles series, I was disappointed with the prophecy-outcast-band of fellows story line that so many high fantasy writers mash together.
I didn’t even finish Jacqueline Carey’s Kushiel’s Dart because it just never grabbed me, and that could be considered high fantasy (mostly?).
If I can figure out the ending by the seventh chapter then I just put the book down. It doesn’t matter the genre, but as a lot of high fantasy is often the same story, I tend to brush past them in the bookstores.
July 8th, 2011 on 3:02 am
Aww. I was reading your entire-fantasy-subgenre-in-a-paragraph and thinking, “That sounds cool, I would read it!” Well, maybe not the whole prophesied one thing, just because it’s unrealistic and done so many times there’s a set standard for it (and many authors like to follow the basic stereotype).
I don’t think teens just don’t like high/epic fantasy because they can’t relate to another world – what about recently popular hits like the Hunger Games, Graceling, and Eragon/Inheritance Cycle? Those all take place in alternate worlds, although HG is dystopian. Teens seem to be more attracted to the whole subject of romance + adventure than relating to their own world (as in, the setting – of course they want to relate with characters, etc).
It doesn’t seem so easy to come up with an original idea like the greats ^.^ But, maybe, one day. The greats seem to be mostly for adults and not children, though – LOTR, George RR Martin, RA Salvatore, etc. (being a hypocrite here, have only read LOTR out of these) – although Narnia is for children, I guess. But I guess maybe teens just care less about cliches and imitations than adults do.
…I’m not being a stalker, am I? Just happened here after a search about epic/high fantasy :p Awesome blog, though. ^.^
July 9th, 2011 on 8:41 pm
Thanks for the comment. And, no, I don’t think you’re a stalker, LOL!
August 1st, 2011 on 5:38 pm
I would think that the above high fantasy plot relates more to the hero’s journey (Joseph Campbell) – the psychology of story-telling – than type-casting an entire genre. It’s classic archetype story-telling. High fantasy relates to the primal (mythic) mind in in a very base way, which is why I think a lot of high fantasy follows a similar plot line – it’s archetypal. It’s not in the plot that the high fantasy becomes interesting – it’s in how it’s told.
Mande