Give Me More – What’s Missing In Popular YA Fantasy

by on Oct.30, 2010, under Fantasy Articles, Writing Tips

I’ve read a ton of novels, and after a while, I started to notice common themes. That made me think about what I wanted to see more of. What are we lacking or what needs improvement? I posed this question to my twitter (YAFantasyGuide) followers and I got some interesting answers. Here’s a list of the top answers:

Gay/Lesbian/Transsexual Characters in Major Roles. I would personally like to see more gay characters who are discovering their sexuality, coming out, and experiencing romantic relationships. These are the issues of many teenagers right now in this country and we should see that played out in young adult novels. This issue isn’t being ignored, but I’d like to see more major characters who are homosexual.

Minority Characters in Major Roles. I’d like to see more Black, Hispanic, Asian, American Indian, etcetera characters in young adult novels. I’m not talking about the stereotype characters. I’ve seen enough Indians on reservations and Japanese martial artists to last a lifetime. I’m talking about main characters in normal day-to-day situations. A reflection of the melting pot society we live in today.

Teenagers in the Middle. We’ve seen the obvious popular, nerd, and outsider kids. But what about the kids in the middle? The ones who make the football team, but aren’t stars. The “C” average kids. Those kids are the ones who represent the majority of us. Mostly, I’d like to see more teenage characters who don’t fall into one specific category.

Female Leads Without a Stronger Male Lead. Teenage girls with power. Tough chicks. You know what I mean. Kick those wallflowers to the side. I for one love to see girls kicking butt. Those are the characters I crave. I hate those books where the female stands to the side while her powerful man saves the day. It’s so popular in fantasy and I’m bored. I’m not saying the tough girls aren’t represented, I’m saying I’d like to see more.

What about you? Comment and tell me what you’d like to see.


5 Comments for this entry

  • Darcy

    I loved this article. It has everything that YA books today need more of! Why can’t the male lead be gay?
    Why can’t the normal average kids have as much fun as the outcasts or popular kids, in fantasy and fiction it’s about things that would never happen in the real world happening … so why can’t this include the average kids?
    Don’t get me started on strong female roles… there just isn’t any lol. Except (Graceling and Fire)

    Love the article and hope authors read it ;)

  • Stacey O'Neale

    Thanks Darcy! I’m glad you liked the article and that you agree with me! ;-p

  • Matthew AT Banning

    I absolutely agree. I have several different characters who show up in my series including a couple gay ones (don’t know that until book two) and a couple minority Characters who will be put into the spotlight. Each book is from a different character perspective. My main character in book one, Dustin, is pretty much an average boy, on the slightly tall side, who’s a natural born leader and everyone looks up to him but he denies he has what it takes to lead.

    I also love my protagonist for book two. She winds up with the ability to “hear” guys thoughts and spends the majority of the book telling them to go away. :D

  • Dyan Mclennan

    Excellent post, thank you so much for sharing. Do you happen to have an RSS feed I can subscribe to?

Leave a Reply