Sex in Young Adult Novels: To Bone or Not to Bone
by Stacey O'Neale on Oct.15, 2010, under Fantasy Articles, Writing Tips
There seems to be a heated debate as to whether or not it’s appropriate to have sex in young adult novels. You can see that the bestsellers have gone all over the spectrum. Some have created teenage lead characters that are sexually active, some develop relationships then have sex, while others wait until marriage.
Here’s are the big questions: What is the moral responsibility of the writer? Should we be politically correct, rely on our own religious beliefs, or are we to stay current?
As a mother, I can certainly see the appeal of encouraging young readers to wait. I hope that my daughter will grow up and want to save herself for marriage. I wouldn’t want to see her get used or mistreated in any way. I pray that I am able to raise her with enough confidence that she makes her own decisions.
Having said that, I can see the other side of this argument. The fact is, teenagers are having sex. They have been for quite a while. Don’t these characters deserve a voice? We have to represent sexually active teenagers as much as we represent the virgins or we’re not be honest. For the record, I have yet to meet a teenager who said they decided to have sex because of the influence of their favorite movie, television, or book character.
I feel that as writers, our responsibly is less to society and more toward the identity of the protagonist that we create. The character has to develop along with the story. Readers will respect you more if your characters are diverse and multi faceted. If you have a relationship between characters then you should see it through even if it means sex. Let the story go where it naturally goes, but if you have characters that are virgins then don’t feel obligated to force them into sexual situations.
Bottom Line: There is no black or white answer in this debate. Personally, I like that we have a variety out there. I really hope I get alot of comments on this because I’m really curious about your opinions.
8 Comments for this entry
1 Trackback or Pingback for this entry
-
You make me feel like I’m living a teenage dream…*: Sex in Young Adult novels « Caleigh's Blog
March 9th, 2011 on 3:03 pm[...] few days ago, Stacey O’Neale of @YAFantasyGuide directed me to this (admittedly ancient) blog post on sex in YA novels. She posed a really interesting question: ‘What is the moral [...]


October 15th, 2010 on 4:20 pm
Love that you are discussing this – I, mother of 5, ages 2-16, believe that it is the responsibility of the parent to educate their own children on the topic. That is not saying that it shouldn’t be written, but that it is up to the parent what they will allow their child to read. Educating your child is #1. Studies have shown that kids who are taught well by their parents, follow the lead of their parents, not the books they are reading, movies they are watching or even what their friends are doing. There are those who fall through the cracks, but again, I don’t believe it is due to what they are reading.
That being said, it is entertainment. period. end of story. What will you as a parent let your child be entertained by? My response thus far may have stumped you as to my opinion – but I have no problem with sex being in a YA book. I would let my teen read it -as well as write it myself if one of my characters called for the action. If it is published as YA, and it is known to have sex in it, I would let my child age 14+ read it.
If we as parents spend parenthood busy hiding things from kids, they are more likely to be intrigued by it in an experimental way later, which can be a dangerous thing -that’s just my experience, coming from an extremely strict upbringing.
October 15th, 2010 on 5:56 pm
I had this conversation with a librarian a few days ago.
I remember books such as Judy Blume’s Forever and Laurie Halse Anderson’s Speak. I think sex needs to be appropriate to the plot. In the Gossip Girl books, most of the characters have sex, but they are foiled by the virginal Jenny Humphrey.
I think if sex is unnecessary to the plot, don’t use it. A skilled author can let the romantic tension linger without using sex as a crutch. Despite my feelings toward Twilight, Stephenie Meyer did a great job prolonging it.
I feel if a YA author uses sex in a novel, the sex should have consequences (either positive or negative).
In my novel, I let the romantic tension linger to the last page where my love birds share their first kiss after sleeping in the same bed, being possessed, and saving the souls of every person in town.
October 16th, 2010 on 12:49 pm
I’m not a mother, I’m a teenager, but my mother did teach me about sex. I think it is the parent’s job to educate their children. I also believe the “right choice” depends on the teenager her/himself. To wait or not to wait is ultimately up to the teenager. And, the “right” choice depends on who they are. I don’t think there is a “right” choice. I also think that YA novels should keep on showing all sides of sex. Already having sexual experience, meeting someone then having sex, and deciding to wait for marriage. Because, ALL those things are reality. Not just one choice, but all those choices. And, even if every YA novel decided for their teenagers to wait until marriage doesn’t mean the teenagers reading the novels will actually wait until marriage. I did just read a novel that had sex in it, but the language was crude and vulgar. I am not opposed to sex in novels, but this was too much for a teenage novel. If they are going to write about sex, I’d like it to be classy.
October 16th, 2010 on 5:54 pm
Like the topic! I have to say, I learned how sex really works through a YA novel. Until then, I had no idea how babies were really made. Seriously! It was my 13th birthday and a friend of mine loaned me this book that was going around like wildfire. I can’t say it would have been good to have learned it some other way. Can’t say I would have WANTED it to be my parents – awkward. But, they had instilled in me their views and a healthy self-esteem. So, once I knew the mechanics, I at least knew what I was missing not having sex. Reading the sex scene in the book actually helped me not to have sex at an early age. It described the experience and some consequences of it afterward (some good some bad.) Again, I am glad I learned what I did the way I did because, well, the parental talk would have weirded me out.
I also think most of the YA sex scenes I read now are not over done or even similar to sex scenes in adult books. Fact is, yes, young adults are having sex and some aren’t. To think a reader would believe a fiction book of two teens in love, having sex, and staying together forever is crazy. Or that sex in a Ya book will be the same in real life. They know teenagers who are in love, have sex, then break up. Or friends that really didn’t like it and tell them why. I think the foundation of the person and their own beliefs will guide their choices. These choices are going to be made with or without a book that has characters having sex. Just be aware when writing the scenes that the audience is young adult.
October 16th, 2010 on 5:58 pm
I agree with you. My priority is always to tell a true story, true to the characters, true to life. My characters struggle with their sexuality and their emerging adulthood. Sometimes I’m proud of their choices, sometimes not, but I’m always careful not to impose an external morality on them.
October 30th, 2010 on 11:22 pm
As a mother and a writer, I also see both sides of the spectrum. Mother outweighs writer without a doubt though. I also agree, although I am not a huge fan of the actual writing inside of the twilight books, I do like the fact that it is held out for a strong period of time, and even when she does get there, it is not what I would consider graphic. I think that the story line can exist tastefully, but I honestly, would not encourage my daughter to read material that describes details of a sex scene. She has been taught about sex, but I am no more likely to support her reading sexually detailed literature than I am to name Ron Jeremy as her Godfather.
January 18th, 2011 on 12:49 pm
I gotta say, the title of this post cracked me up – “to bone or not to bone.”
It’s a good question, and I think ultimately you’re right, you’ve gotta stay true to your characters – I do also like the comment that sex should have ramifications – for good and/or bad. You can have a YA novel that’s all about sex (I’m thinking of Ellen Hopkins’ “Tricks” which is about teen sex workers) but there are serious consequences and a deep exploration of the difference between sex and intimacy – a challenging and thought-provoking book. And maybe that’s what we want – for the sex in YA to be thought-provoking, not just titillating.
Great stuff to discuss and consider!
Thanks,
Namaste,
Lee
March 20th, 2011 on 6:06 pm
Excellent topic! I’m writing the sequel to my debut YA novel and struggling with this very thing. In the first book, there is no sex. Plenty of romantic moments, but no sex. The protagonist is still in high school. By the second book, she’s older so I’m wondering about how far this romance will go.
As was stated by an earlier commenter about restricting younger teens from a “sexy” book, I don’t want to limit my audience. On a personal level, I’ve taught my own children to wait. But as a writer, I want the relationship to develop naturally for the characters. Throw in there that the protagonist is Catholic (not a major point of the book, but a detail to consider), and I’ve got a lot to work through.
Ultimately, it sounds like the consensus is: Sex has to make sense for the story, and I agree strongly with the comment that sex has consequences (good and/or bad). That’s the lesson I want my kids to understand.
Anne Greenwood Brown
LIES BENEATH
Random House/ Delacorte, summer 2012