The Worst Writing Advice I’ve Ever Heard

by on Oct.10, 2010, under Writing Tips

Everybody’s got an opinion, even when you don’t ask for one. I think this is especially true when you’re a writer. It seems like everybody’s got an idea of what you need to do to become the next bestseller. For fun, I opened this question up to our Twitter followers and got some really interesting responses. Here are my picks for the WORST writing advice.

You Must Write Short Stories Before Attempting A Novel. I have to say from personal experience that I hate writing short stories. I just have too much detail in my head to cut it down. If you have a story there then write it. Don’t worry about your writing experience, let the words flow on their own and don’t try to dictate where it goes.

Never Break The Rules. I agree and disagree on this one. If a sentence needs a comma, then put it there. Those types of rules are pretty solid. But, when dealing with dialogue, I especially think you need to break a few rules. Your characters need to sound like people, not robots (unless your novel is about robots). Children and teenagers have their own lingo which you may not find in the latest Cambridge Advanced Learner’s Dictionary so keep that in mind for those characters.

You Must Participate In A Critique Group. Some critique groups are great and offer sound advice, but not all. Just because someone calls themselves a writer doesn’t mean they’re in any position to offer advice. This is especially true if they don’t write in your genre. I mean, I could probably offer advice about fantasy writing just because I read it and write all the time, but if you asked me about science fiction or horror then I’d be lost. Critique groups can be great, but be cautious with their input into your story.

Stick To What You Know. I can’t help laughing as I write that. If we only wrote about what we know then we wouldn’t have fantasy, horror, paranormal, or science fiction novels. We’d have nothing but non-fiction. I say, write what you love. If all you read is fantasy then write fantasy. To me, this is a no brainer.

Stop Writing. I hate this one. Way to crush someone’s dream. If anyone tells you this then just cut them off and walk away. Never let anyone tell you to quit what you love. Never let anyone tell you that what you have isn’t enough. I’d say, if you doubt your skills then write more and work hard at improving your craft, but never give up. Rejections are part of life. J.K. Rowling’s was rejected by eleven publishers before signing a deal for Harry Potter! Stephenie Meyer received seven rejections from agencies who didn’t think Twilight was publishable. Final verdict, keep writing and keep believing in yourself!


6 Comments for this entry

  • laradunning

    Stacey this is great! Since there was such a long break inbetween short stories written in my youth and the novel I embarked upon two years ago, one could say I started writing the novel first. I wrote a short horror story inbetween after having a really creepy dream. But otherwise it was my fantasy novel that took up all of my extra time. I agree too about your comment about critique groups. I think it is really important to have a group in your genre as they often offer more insight on certain issues that arise. Its good to know that the most beloved books out there received rejection first. Sometimes you have to be your own best cheerleader.

  • Rusty Fischer

    How about: Boys don’t read!

    I’ve heard this soooooo many times I can’t believe it!

    Great blog, and super comments; glad I checked it out and will def do so again…

    Rusty

    • Stacey O'Neale

      I totally agree and if you read agent blogs you will see that there is a strong market right now for young adult books geared toward teenage boys!

      • Rusty Fischer

        Absolutely; it just goes to show you can’t follow trends or take everything you hear as gospel. You have to stick to your guns and write what YOU feel is right; if it’s good enough, and honest enough, it WILL find an audience. Thanks for the reply!!!!

  • Stacey O'Neale

    Thanks for pointing that out. I am an admittted terrible speller, but I forgot about the title, LOL! Glad you liked the article anyway! :)

1 Trackback or Pingback for this entry

Leave a Reply